| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 27.12.2023 - today | ROH World Tag Team Champion (3x) (with Matt Taven as The Undisputed Kingdom) | 118 days | Matches |
| 05.11.2022 - 06.01.2024 | Pale Pro Champion | 427 days | Matches |
| 09.07.2022 - 03.12.2022 | PWR Tag Team Champion (with Matt Taven as The OGK) | 147 days | Matches |
| 26.08.2022 - 08.10.2022 | Impact World Tag Team Champion (with Matt Taven as Honor No More) | 43 days | Matches |
| 14.11.2021 - 11.12.2021 | ROH World Tag Team Champion (2x) (with Matt Taven as The OGK) | 27 days | Matches |
| 05.08.2019 - 05.08.2019 | WWE 24/7 Champion (2x) (as Mike Kanellis) | <1 day | Matches |
| 29.07.2019 - 29.07.2019 | WWE 24/7 Champion (as Mike Kanellis) | <1 day | Matches |
| 03.03.2017 - 18.03.2017 | NEW Heavyweight Champion | 15 days | Matches |
| 14.06.2016 - 15.06.2016 | TNA X-Division Champion | 1 day | Matches |
| 18.09.2015 - 18.12.2015 | ROH World Tag Team Champion (as Michael Bennett; with Matt Taven as The Kingdom) | 91 days | Matches |
| 05.04.2015 - 05.07.2015 | IWGP Tag Team Champion (as Michael Bennett; with Matt Taven as The Kingdom) | 91 days | Matches |
| 26.04.2012 - 28.02.2014 | PWE United States Champion | 673 days | Matches |
| 04.04.2009 - 09.04.2010 | TRP Heavyweight Champion | 370 days | Matches |
| 01.05.2009 - 13.03.2010 | NCW Tag Team Champion (with Chris Venom and Johnny Idol as The Heatseekers) | 316 days | Matches |
| 05.01.2007 - xx.01.2008 | TRP Tag Team Champion (with Bryce Andrews as The Metro Men) | ? | Matches |
| 16.12.2005 - 06.01.2006 | WFA Tag Team Champion (2x) (as The Mike ; with The Shane as The Metro Men) | 21 days | Matches |
| 23.07.2004 - xx.xx.2004 | WFA Tag Team Champion (as The Mike ; with The Ray as The Metro Men) | ? | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| IWGP Tag Team Championship | 91 days |
| NCW Tag Team Championship | 316 days |
| NEW Heavyweight Championship | 15 days |
| Pale Pro Championship | 427 days |
| PWE United States Championship | 673 days |
| PWR Tag Team Championship | 147 days |
| ROH World Tag Team Championship (3x) | 236 days |
| TNA World Tag Team Championship | 43 days |
| TNA X-Division Championship | 1 day |
| TRP Heavyweight Championship | 370 days |
| TRP Tag Team Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| WFA Tag Team Championship (2x) | 21 (+ ?) days |
| WWE 24/7 Championship (2x) | <1 day |
