| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 28.09.2019 - 11.01.2020 | RWA No Limits Champion (as Jimmy Cicero) | 105 days | Matches |
| 19.05.2018 - 07.07.2018 | RWA Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Jimmy Cicero; with The Great Akuma) | 49 days | Matches |
| 10.06.2017 - 20.01.2018 | RWA Tag Team Champion (as Jimmy Cicero; with Ron Hunt) | 224 days | Matches |
| 21.05.2016 - xx.08.2016 | RWA Pennsylvania Regional Champion (as Jimmy Cicero) | ? | Matches |
| 28.03.2015 - 27.02.2016 | RWA Heavyweight Champion (as Jimmy Cicero) | 336 days | Matches |
| 17.12.2009 - xx.08.2010 | NWA Continental Heavyweight Champion (as Jimmy Cicero) | ? | Matches |
| 28.06.2009 - 25.04.2010 | APWF Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Jimmy Cicero) | 301 days | Matches |
| 27.06.2002 - 23.11.2002 | SCW Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Jimmy Cicero) | 149 days | Matches |
| 06.12.2000 - 18.05.2001 | MCW Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Jimmy Cicero) | 163 days | Matches |
| 10.05.2000 - xx.xx.2000 | SCW Tag Team Champion (as Jimmy Cicero; with Cueball Carmichael) | ? | Matches |
| 19.07.2000 - 19.11.2000 | MCW Heavyweight Champion (as Jimmy Cicero) | 123 days | Matches |
| 30.07.1999 - xx.xx.1999 | APWF Television Champion (as Jimmy Cicero) | ? | Matches |
| 23.01.1999 - xx.xx.1999 | IPWA Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Jimmy Cicero; with Cueball Carmichael) | ? | Matches |
| 08.07.1999 - 13.11.1999 | MCW Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Jimmy Cicero; with Romeo Valentino) | 128 days | Matches |
| 16.04.1999 - 15.05.1999 | APWF Heavyweight Champion (as Jimmy Cicero) | 29 days | Matches |
| 02.09.1998 - 09.01.1999 | IPWA Tag Team Champion (as Jimmy Cicero; with Cueball Carmichael) | 129 days | Matches |
| 20.09.1998 - 04.11.1998 | MCW Tag Team Champion (as Jimmy Cicero; with Julio Sanchez) | 45 days | Matches |
| 17.01.1998 - 27.06.1998 | SCW Heavyweight Champion (as Jimmy Cicero) | 161 days | Matches |
| 19.02.1998 - 13.06.1998 | IPWA Heavyweight Champion (as Jimmy Cicero) | 114 days | Matches |
| 18.07.1997 - 03.01.1998 | NWA 2000 Heavyweight Champion (as Jimmy Cicero) | 169 days | Matches |
| 13.11.1997 - 22.12.1997 | MEWF Tag Team Champion (4x) (as Jimmy Cicero; with Julio Sanchez) | 39 days | Matches |
| 18.10.1997 - 23.10.1997 | MEWF Tag Team Champion (3x) (as Jimmy Cicero; with Steve Corino) | 5 days | Matches |
| 10.08.1997 - 17.09.1997 | MEWF Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Jimmy Cicero; with Steve Corino) | 38 days | Matches |
| 29.06.1997 - 17.07.1997 | MEWF Tag Team Champion (as Jimmy Cicero; with Steve Corino) | 18 days | Matches |
| 01.12.1996 - 01.06.1997 | MEWF Mid-Atlantic Champion (as Jimmy Cicero) | 182 days | Matches |
| 22.04.1995 - 20.04.1996 | SCW Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Jimmy Cicero; with Brian Perry as The Rat Pack) | 364 days | Matches |
| 17.11.1994 - 25.03.1995 | SCW Tag Team Champion (as Jimmy Cicero; with Brian Perry as The Rat Pack) | 128 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| APWF Heavyweight Championship (2x) | 330 days |
| APWF Television Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| Fusion Wrestling Heavyweight Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| IPWA Heavyweight Championship | 114 days |
| IPWA Tag Team Championship (2x) | 129 (+ ?) days |
| MCW Heavyweight Championship (2x) | 286 days |
| MCW Tag Team Championship (2x) | 173 days |
| MEWF Mid-Atlantic Championship | 182 days |
| MEWF Tag Team Championship (4x) | 100 days |
| NWA 2000 Heavyweight Championship | 169 days |
| RWA Heavyweight Championship | 336 days |
| RWA No Limits Championship | 105 days |
| RWA Pennsylvania Regional Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| RWA Tag Team Championship (2x) | 273 days |
| SCW Heavyweight Championship (2x) | 310 days |
| SCW Tag Team Championship (2x) | 492 days |
| SCW Tag Team Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
