[3.0] "Er sieht aus wie Jay Lethal in langweilig. Ich fand ihn bei AEW sowohl als Tag Team Champion, als auch als TNT Champion deplatziert. Auch an der Seite des sehr guten Dan Lambert ist er immer noch farblos und langweilig. Im Ring ist er solide, aber auch nichts besonderes. Und da er auch schon recht alt ist, kann man auch auf keine Entwicklung mehr hoffen."
[5.0] "Scorpio Sky was good when he was teaming with Christopher Daniels & Frankie Kazarian in SCU, and he's always been a good wrestler, his biggest flaw is that he has no personality on his own. No charisma, no personality and his promos are beyond boring to watch, give him a mouthpiece (that isn't Dan Lambert) and he could, possibly, get over."
[8.0] "Ich glaube ich habe Sky hier schon mal bewertet. Ist ja ärgerlich das mein Kommentar zu ihm weg ist. Aktuell gefällt er mir auch bei ROH und mit seinen Buddies aus der So-Cal Wrestling Szene. Ansonst kenne ich ihn noch sehr gut von PWG mit Maske und dann ohne. Top Wrestler und etwas unterschätzt. Edit 19.09.2023 war lange wegen einer schweren Beinverletzung von Juli 2022 bis Juni 2023 verletzt. Ich hoffe ja das Sky die nächsten Monate mal ohne schwere Verletzungen auskommt."
[3.0] "Akzeptabel im Tag Team- Bereich, als Einzelwrestler jedoch komplett aufgeschmissen. Mit viel Wohlwollen ist Sky in allen Belangen durchschnittlich. Ist deshalb bei einer Promotion im nationalen TV mehr als deplatziert und wenn überhaupt als Filler in den Indys zu gebrauchen."
[6.0] "Skye has a superstar look and he got a great push to the AEW Tag Team Championship with SCU. But when I see him as a singles guy, I'm frequently underwhelmed. He feels like he should be better than he is, but his style doesn't seem to take advantage of his athleticism. He's often trying a technical style that he's not great at."
[4.0] "This score is pretty much all down to his longevity. He's got a great look and you want to think there's something there but he's never shown it. I can't recall a great match or promo at all."
[4.0] "Bin nie mit Scorpio Sky warm geworden, er ist mir nie sympathisch gewesen. Seine Promos, seine Wrestlingskills und seine Ausstrahlung liegen im absoluten Mittelfeld, kann mir ihn eigentlich nirgendwo richtig vorstellen außer irgendwo in der Midcard."
[6.0] "Really good in the ring, but he has no charisma and is bland as hell. His run with the TNT title really exposed his weaknesses. Should just be a tag team guy who doesn? t speak much."
[5.0] "The best thing he ever had going for him was being a part of SCU. Without that, I see no reason to care about this guy. His charisma is low, it is very hard to remember any of his matches, you have to look them up on Cagematch for them to ring a bell. Ethan Page tops him as a personality. Dan Lambert is doing the majority of all his talking. He is extremely uninteresting as TNT Champion, and I have NO IDEA why he holds that title. He definitely will end up having a forgettable reign with that title. AEW had awesome champions like Cody, Darby Allin, Sammy Guevara, & Miro. I don't see Scorpio Sky coming anywhere near to what those guys were. He has already said that he is not doing "Open door" challenges. That hurts him more than helps him, because it shows that he doesn't have the balls to take on all comers. Pretty lame excuse to hold that title without really ever defending it, thus holding it hostage. Someone like Swerve Strickland would make an excellent TNT Champion, he has the feel as one. Scorpio Sky should have been kept in the Tag Team ranks. Right now, he is involved in arguably the worst feud in AEW as of early 2022: Sammy Guevara & Tay Conti vs. American Top Team & Men of the Year. UPDATED: Yep, Scorpio Sky's title reign has been forgettable, as he hasn't done a damn thing with that title, and it looks like he is about to lose it to Wardlow hopefully. This should be THE LAST title that Scorpio Sky ever holds, I hope."
[4.0] "One of the most bland wrestlers on the AEW roster. His matches are technically sound but never make it beyond 'mediocre' and often don't even get to that level. He also has no charisma whatsoever. I can't make any sense of his current push."
[2.0] "Sky was the inaugural AEW Tag Champ (when it should've been Lucha Bros), the Face of the Revolution ladder match winner, and now a 2-time TNT Champion...and yet somehow still manages to be one of the most boring charisma vacuums on the entire roster. Putting him with the entertaining Dan Lambert and Ethan Page, who is more talented than him in every facet of the word was probably not the best idea because it highlights how boring Sky is. His in-ring work is nothing you haven't seen before and he has nothing that sets him apart from everyone else. He and Sammy have singlehandedly tarnished a title that the previous titleholders worked so hard to make important."
[6.0] "Der Kerl ist schon wirklich ziemlich ordentlich. Mit den MotY und dem American Top Team funktioniert er an sich ganz gut. Aber ich finde nicht, dass es bei ihm für mehr als Midcard reicht, was vielleicht auch an der Darstellung liegen mag. Im Ring ist er ganz gut, Charisma ist vorhanden, wenn auch nicht übermäßig. Dazu ist er okay am Mikro, aber gerade bei AEW gibt es so viele, die als Gesamtpaket klar besser sind und aktuell klar unter ihm stehen."
[4.0] "Perfectly average, which doesn't play well on a grand scale. Better suited for tag teams but even then he struggles to stand out, like in the completely forgettable inaugural reign for the AEW tag team championship."
[5.0] "Pretty much 'meh' in every way, in my opinion. People were more interested with SCU as a unit rather than Scorpio individually. He's a talented highflyer turned allrounder, who's had a solid career in indies like ROH, PWG and now AEW. Lacks an ounce of charisma, which evens him out to being a 5. His latest run in Men of the Year hasn't been my thing. The only reason he's gotten babyface reactions against Sammy Guevara is because the fans hate Sammy."
[3.0] "It pains me to watch the matches of Scorpio Sky, because he seems to embody a certain plasticity that is increasingly found among wrestlers. For example: I hate Guevara, I don't like what he does and how he does his job, but at the same time he has some kind of identity, and I understand why some part of a particularly narrow audience adores him. Scorpio knows how to move inside the ring, knows the basics of wrestling, but he is incredibly boring and can't fix it in any way. It is a huge mistake that his name is recorded in the history of AEW as the first tag team champion."
[6.0] "In the ring he's pretty good. As a tag team guy he's pretty good. As a face he's okay. That's about it. Unfortunately he falls short everywhere else. He has a boring look, overshadowed by his new heel tag partner, not very good with scripted backstage promos or on a live mic. He was red hot before the pandemic started but being off tv for a few months and lack luster fueds and being paired with Dan Lambert has made him cool off significantly to the point where I have no interest in him. It's a shame because he seems like a decent person and he is slowly getting better but with AEW's current landscape he needs to step up massively or he will get left behind with the absolutely stacked roster they currently have."
[6.0] "I guess I'm in the minority of people who actually enjoys Scorpio far more since his heel turn. With SCU, it felt like there were too many in-jokes I didn't get because of the Being the Elite youtube show they were popularised through, and Scorpio just seemed like a very generic 'smiley hard-worker'. Since his heel turn he's been a lot more engaging with his confident delivery and an actual direction with his character work. His in-ring work has always been good at worst, so he's now put it all together to become a good mid-card heel. The standard heel shenanigans that drag his matches down are still annoying, but he also still shows that he's a good in-ring worker whenever he wants to, and I guess for whatever reason I just find his heel character work somewhat compelling. He's definitely not one of my favourite parts of AEW or anything, but I definitely think he's got a suitable place in the company."
[6.0] "He's pretty darn good in the ring. That by itself is an 8. Everything else is 'fine'. Not a great promo when compared to Ethan Page and Lambert. As of today, he's the TNT champion and probably the least impressive champion they've had. If SCU was still a thing, he would probably be better off. He needs something else not sure what."
[8.0] "He's always very good in the ring and can do fairly well on the microphone. Its really more a case of he's good at a lot but doesn't seem to be great enough to get that main even level"
[5.0] "Scorpio Sky is definitely a good worker, but that's all he has going for him. No charisma, below average promos, boring look. AEW have tried multiple times to get this guy over as a singles guy but it never works out and then they just stuff him back into the bloated tag division to rot on Dark. He was good in SCU, but he's since branched off from them and turned heel and joined Ethan Page, whom he has no chemistry with. Good worker but nothing more than that"
[6.0] "He's missing something and at this stage in his career I don't think he's gonna find it. He's really solid though and a better than average "good hand""
[6.0] "Er scheint fast ein unumgänglicher Kandidat zu sein, aber sein Charisma ist einfach nicht da, um ihn zu tragen. Jedes Mal, wenn er ans Mikrofon geht, kommt er weniger rüber. Sein Heel Turn hat nur ein bisschen geholfen, aber ich glaube nicht, dass er zu diesem Zeitpunkt viel an ihm hat. Schade, denn im Ring ist er sehr gut."
[8.0] "Underrated guy. He is really good in ring and as a tag team wrestler also. His mic skills are acceptable but he never got the fame he deserves. I'll love to see him having a championship in AEW. I would rate him 8."
[9.0] "Wie kann Scorpio Sky hier bei unter 7 Punkten stehen? Im Ring ist er wirklich athletisch und Talent für Comedy besitzt er auch. Zusammen mit seinen SCU Bros bildet er meiner Meinung nach einen der besten Acts im Wrestling."
[6.0] "Probably the least compelling of the SCU trio, but he's got a good gig right now & I wouldn't change a thing. He's good in the ring & if that group does ever break up down the line, it will be interesting to see if Sky can make it as a solo act."
[10.0] "Seen him live several times one of the single greatest who can't seem to get deserved recognition. A great blend of striking submission martial arts style , with high flying and traditional wrestling maneuvers effortlessly transitioned and executed."
[8.0] "Ich kann mich sehr für Scorpio Sky begeistern. Der gute Mann ist im Ring auf jeden Fall eine Granate. Gute Leistungen zuhauf. Natürlich wrestlet er fast aussschließlich in Kalifornien aber dort kann er bei PWG eigentliche jedes mal im Ring überzeugen. Das der gute Mann auch am Mic etwas drauf hat merkt man erst wenn man ihn mal bei der damaligen NWA from Hollywood, der jetzigen CWF, gesehen hat. Großartiger arroganter Heel mittlerweile der mir in der Rolle gut gefällt."
[7.0] "Scorpio Sky (Mason Andrews) is a very good wrestler, who had a good stint in TNA recently apart from his frequent appearances in NWA Championship Wrestling from Hollywood."
[7.0] "Scorpio Sky ist ein wirklich guter Wrestler, der im Ring überzeugt, aber leider zum einen irgendwie nicht über die SoCal Szene hinaus kommt und generell etwas in der Indy Masse untergeht. Zur Zeit bei PWG im Team mit Ryan aber sehr gut aufgehoben."
[7.0] "Guter Wrestler, ich finde es nur schade, dass er bei PWG zur Zeit meistens im Team mit Ronin antritt. Ich würde ihn lieber wieder als Singles Wrestler sehen."
[9.0] "Ausgezeichneter und sehr sicherer Wrestler. Schade, daß er nie wirklich aus SoCal rauszukommen scheint und auch bei Pro Wrestling Guerrilla nie die großen Erfolge feiern durfte, obwohl er seit Jahr und Tag mehr als solide Leistungen zeigt."
