[7.0] "One of the bright spots, along with The FBI and Nova, of what was an afterthought of a tag division towards the end of ECW. Got a decent reaction from the crowd and was deceptively quick for a huge guy dressed in a cheap shirt and trousers. Had a great planted powerbomb, Amish Splash that covered over half the ring and was athletic enough to do a rope walk and step up top rope dive to the outside. Think they were the final ECW champs, their title win at Massacre On 34th Street is a fun 10 minute spot fest. Seems a bit of a waste that a guy with promising potential did nothing beyond developmental, and not since 2007."
[7.0] "An high flying/brawler who could do basically anything. His amish gimmick is...an amish gimmick, it's certainly different. There's probably a ceiling as to where you can take a gimmick like that (such as the fact that I've never seen a promo by him), but he was a capable wrestler and could deliver some good wrestling. I wish he was used more in WWECW, he was still 30 there"
[6.0] "Roadkill was pretty agile for a Big Man, had a really good and fun gimmick, I think that rumor about facing Taker at Mania was hilarious and I kinda wish it happened."
[3.0] "Roadkill was a subpar talent who lucked into a gimmick that somewhat covered for his lack of ability. He may have had a decent post-ECW run, but he priced himself out of the market by thinking more highly of himself than anyone else did."
[6.0] "I liked Roadkill. He had some surprising agility for a big dude, and the "Angry Amish Chicken-Plucker" gimmick is just one of those fun, out-there characters I often gravitate towards. It was certainly a funny contrast with partner Danny Doring's sleazy character, and Roadkill and Doring were certainly at their best together - they weren't the last ECW Tag Champs for nothing. Glad to have seen what may be his last-ever match at the first House of Hardcore show live."
[7.0] "Als Amish Chicken Plucker einfach nur Kult. Schade, dass die WWE ihn nicht so eingesetzt hat. Mit dem Gimmick hätte er auch im Main Roster Erfolg haben können."
[4.0] "Hat mit Danny Doring ein guten Tag Team Partner gehabt, aber allein das reicht nicht aus, um Roadkill positiv zu bewerten, denn im Ring hat er mich nicht begeistern können!"
[4.0] "Das Gimmick als Roadkill fand ich richtig gut. Für seine Statur ist er durchaus in der Lage auch ansehnliche Matches zu bestreiten, also immer recht solide. Ich würde es begrüßen ihn bald wieder in der WWE zu sehen, denn da gibt es Leute die schlechter sind als er."