| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 19.01.2024 |  |
Four Way: Matthew Riddle defeats Bestia 666 and Dralistico and Brian Cage The Crash - Event @ Auditorio de Tijuana in Tijuana, Baja California, Mexiko |
| 2 | 25.05.2018 |  |
Matthew Riddle defeats David Starr (18:22) PWG Bask In His Glory - Event @ American Legion Post #308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 3 | 11.05.2018 |  |
Aussie Open (Kyle Fletcher & Mark Davis) defeat The Chosen Bros (Jeff Cobb & Matthew Riddle) (15:22) RevPro Epic Encounter 2018 - Event @ York Hall in London, England, UK |
| 4 | 16.02.2018 | |
Keith Lee defeats Matthew Riddle (18:27) PWG Neon Knights - Event @ American Legion Post #308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 5 | 12.01.2018 | |
PWG World Tag Team Title: The Chosen Bros (Jeff Cobb & Matthew Riddle) (c) defeat Ringkampf (Timothy Thatcher & WALTER) (18:29) PWG Mystery Vortex V - Event @ American Legion Post #308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 6 | 29.10.2017 |  |
Matthew Riddle defeats JT Dunn Beyond Apocalypse Dudes - Online Stream @ Electric Haze in Worcester, Massachusetts, USA |
| 7 | 20.10.2017 | |
PWG World Tag Team Title: The Chosen Bros (Jeff Cobb & Matthew Riddle) defeat The Lucha Brothers (Penta el 0M & Rey Fenix) (c) (17:39) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PWG All Star Weekend 13 - Tag 1 - Event @ American Legion Post #308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 8 | 03.09.2017 | |
Battle Of Los Angeles 2017 Quarter Final: Matthew Riddle defeats Penta El Zero M (14:18) PWG Battle Of Los Angeles 2017 - Tag 3 - Event @ American Legion Post 308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 9 | 03.09.2017 | |
Battle Of Los Angeles 2017 Semi Final: Jeff Cobb defeats Matthew Riddle (9:05) PWG Battle Of Los Angeles 2017 - Tag 3 - Event @ American Legion Post 308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 10 | 02.09.2017 | |
Battle Of Los Angeles 2017 First Round: Matthew Riddle defeats Michael Elgin (17:59) PWG Battle Of Los Angeles 2017 - Tag 2 - Event @ American Legion Post #308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 11 | 01.09.2017 | |
Chosen Bros (Jeff Cobb & Matthew Riddle) defeat Donovan Dijak & Keith Lee (18:25) PWG Battle Of Los Angeles 2017 - Tag 1 - Event @ American Legion Post #308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 12 | 13.08.2017 | |
Doom Patrol (Chris Dickinson & Jaka) defeat The Chosen Bros (Jeff Cobb & Matthew Riddle) (15:46) Beyond Bye Bye Beautiful - Event @ Arts At The Armory in Somerville, Massachusetts, USA |
| 13 | 19.05.2017 | |
The Chosen Bros (Jeff Cobb & Matthew Riddle) defeat reDRagon (Bobby Fish & Kyle O'Reilly) (15:58) PWG Head Like A Cole - Event @ American Legion Post 308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 14 | 21.04.2017 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Adam Cole (13:50) PWG Game Over, Man - Event @ American Legion Hall 308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 15 | 01.04.2017 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Donovan Dijak (11:10) Beyond Caffeine - Pay Per View @ Orlando Live Events in Fern Park, Florida, USA |
| 16 | 18.03.2017 | |
The Chosen Bros (Jeff Cobb & Matthew Riddle) defeat OI4K (Dave Crist & Jake Crist) (16:47) PWG Nice Boys (Don't Play Rock N' Roll) - Event @ American Legion Post 308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 17 | 17.03.2017 |  |
WC Ringmaster Title: Brian Cage (c) defeats Matthew Riddle WC SXWWrestleCircus - Event @ Emo's in Austin, Texas, USA |
| 18 | 18.02.2017 | |
The Chosen Bros (Jeff Cobb & Matthew Riddle) defeat The Unbreakable F'N Machines (Brian Cage & Michael Elgin) (14:43) PWG Only Kings Understand Each Other - Event @ American Legion Post #308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 19 | 29.01.2017 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Brian Cage (8:27) Beyond Paying Paul - Event @ Electric Haze in Worcester, Massachusetts, USA |
| 20 | 29.12.2016 | |
Chuck O'Neil & Matthew Riddle defeat Team Tremendous (Bill Carr & Dan Barry) Beyond Party Animals - Event @ Aurora in Providence, Rhode Island, USA |
| 21 | 16.12.2016 | |
Jeff Cobb & Matthew Riddle defeat The Young Bucks (Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson) (18:47) PWG Mystery Vortex IV - Event @ American Legion Post #308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 22 | 11.12.2016 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Dan Barry (10:00) Beyond Over-Nite Sensation - Pay Per View @ Melrose Memorial Hall in Melrose, Massachusetts, USA |
| 23 | 06.11.2016 |  |
Men's Tournament For Today 2016 First Round: Matthew Riddle defeats Chris Dickinson (6:34) Beyond/WWR Tournament For Today - Show 1 - Event @ Aurora in Providence, Rhode Island, USA |
| 24 | 06.11.2016 | |
Men's Tournament For Today 2016 Final: Matthew Riddle defeats Donovan Dijak (6:34) Beyond/WWR Tournament For Today - Show 2 - Event @ Aurora in Providence, Rhode Island, USA |
| 25 | 06.11.2016 | |
Men's Tournament For Today 2016 Semi Final: Matthew Riddle defeats Jonathan Gresham (5:57) Beyond/WWR Tournament For Today - Show 2 - Event @ Aurora in Providence, Rhode Island, USA |
| 26 | 08.10.2016 |  |
QPW Title: Adam Thornstowe (c) defeats Matthew Riddle QPW Quintapalooza! - Event @ American Legion in Baldwin Park, California, USA |
| 27 | 02.10.2016 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Jaka (11:21) Beyond Midas Touch - Event @ Arts At The Armory in Somerville, Massachusetts, USA |
| 28 | 04.09.2016 | |
Cedric Alexander, Chuck Taylor, Jeff Cobb, Jushin Thunder Liger & Tommy End defeat Brian Kendrick, Matthew Riddle, Pete Dunne, Sami Callihan & Tommaso Ciampa (17:39) PWG Battle Of Los Angeles 2016 - Tag 3 - Event @ American Legion Post #308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 29 | 03.09.2016 | |
Battle Of Los Angeles 2016 First Round: Kyle O'Reilly defeats Matthew Riddle (16:09) PWG Battle Of Los Angeles 2016 - Tag 2 - Event @ American Legion Post #308 in Reseda, California, USA |
| 30 | 28.08.2016 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Chris Dickinson (14:41) Beyond Battle Of Who Could Care Less - Event @ Aurora in Providence, Rhode Island, USA |
| 31 | 31.07.2016 |  |
Matthew Riddle defeats John Silver (10:55) Beyond Americanrana 2016 - Event @ Fete Music in Providence, Rhode Island, USA |
| 32 | 17.07.2016 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Tommaso Ciampa (15:43) Beyond Flesh - Pay Per View @ Melrose Memorial Hall in Melrose, Massachusetts, USA |
| 33 | 10.07.2016 |  |
Darius Carter & Gran Akuma defeat Matthew Riddle & Rude Boy Riley Tier 1 One Year Later - Event @ St. Finbar Catholic Church in New York City, New York, USA |
| 34 | 09.07.2016 |  |
Matthew Riddle defeats Delirious (14:18) MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 35 | 26.06.2016 | |
Steel Cage European Rules: Matthew Riddle defeats Chuck O'Neil (13:23) Beyond Ripped Off In The Prime Of Life - Event @ Arts At The Amory in Somerville, Massachusetts, USA |
| 36 | 17.06.2016 |  |
Matthew Riddle defeats Chuck O'Neil Beyond/HOG - Event @ NYC Arena in New York City, New York, USA |
| 37 | 29.05.2016 | |
Matthew Riddle vs. Tommaso Ciampa - No Contest (12:25) Beyond C5 - A Fundraiser For Brandon Watts - Event @ Aurora in Providence, Rhode Island, USA |
| 38 | 28.05.2016 | |
Monster's Ball: Abyss, Matthew Riddle & Punisher Martinez defeat Beast Cartel (Fallah Bahh, Kyle The Beast & Nick Comoroto) (18:24) MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 39 | 20.05.2016 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Caleb Konley Tier 1 Meteoric - Event @ American Legion in New York City, New York, USA |
| 40 | 14.05.2016 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Fallah Bahh MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 41 | 30.04.2016 | |
Match (Referee: Billy Damiana): Matthew Riddle defeats Nick Comoroto by DQ (11:41) MFPW Fans Appreciation Night - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 42 | 24.04.2016 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Suge D (5:14) Beyond Head Over Heels - Event @ Arts At The Amory in Somerville, Massachusetts, USA |
| 43 | 16.04.2016 | |
MFPW Heavyweight Title #1 Contendership Four Way: Kyle The Beast defeats Matthew Riddle and Mikey Webb and Shaheem Ali MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 44 | 26.03.2016 |  |
KPW Tag Team Title: Ultimate Punishment (Matthew Riddle & Punisher Martinez) defeat The Maulers Of Barnari (Ace Klopenza & Jason Gotti) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! KPW Against All Odds - Event @ Host & Conference Center in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 45 | 28.02.2016 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Mike Bailey (5:43) Beyond State Of The Art - Event @ Aurora in Providence, Rhode Island, USA |
| 46 | 13.02.2016 | |
KPW Tag Team Title: Ultimate Punishment (Matthew Riddle & Punisher Martinez) defeat The Maulers Of Barnari (Ace Klopenza & Jason Gotti) (c) by DQ KPW Under Siege - Event @ Host & Conference Center in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 47 | 31.01.2016 | |
Match (Special Guest Referee: Drew Gulak): Matthew Riddle defeats Chuck O'Neil (5:16) Beyond The Dream Left Behind - Event @ Arts At The Amory in Somerville, Massachusetts, USA |
| 48 | 16.01.2016 | |
Ultimate Punishment (Matthew Riddle & Punisher Martinez) defeat The Black Wall Street (Napalm Bomb & Solo) KPW Starting Point - Event @ Host & Conference Center in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 49 | 09.01.2016 | |
MF Cup Tournament 2016 First Round: ExerGuys (JP & M3) defeat Matthew Riddle & Nick Comoroto MFPW MF Cup 2016 - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 50 | 27.12.2015 | |
Catch Point (Drew Gulak & Matthew Riddle) defeat Chuck O'Neil & Eric Spicely (8:33) Beyond Fete Finale - Event @ Fete Music in Providence, Rhode Island, USA |
| 51 | 26.12.2015 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Dalton Castle LCW - Saturday Show - Event @ Host & Conference Center in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 52 | 12.12.2015 | |
Street Fight: Cliff Compton defeats Matthew Riddle MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 53 | 05.12.2015 |  |
David Starr defeats Matthew Riddle Legacy Wrestling Dangerous Encouters - Event @ Spooky Nook Sports in Manheim, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 54 | 29.11.2015 | |
Chuck O'Neil, Eric Spicely & Matthew Riddle defeat The Amazing Gulaks (Drew Gulak & Rory Gulak) & Tracy Williams (13:46) Beyond Tournament For Tomorrow 4 - Tag 2 - Event @ Fete Music in Providence, Rhode Island, USA |
| 55 | 10.10.2015 | |
MFPW Heavyweight Title Three Way: Nick Comoroto (c) defeats Clutch Adams and Matthew Riddle MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 56 | 05.09.2015 | |
MFPW Heavyweight Title: Matthew Riddle (c) defeats Silas Young MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 57 | 22.08.2015 | |
MFPW Heavyweight Title: Matthew Riddle (c) defeats Clutch Adams MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 58 | 08.08.2015 | |
MFPW Heavyweight Title: Matthew Riddle (c) defeats Punisher Martinez (15:29) MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 59 | 25.07.2015 | |
MFPW Heavyweight Title: Matthew Riddle (c) defeats Clutch Adams MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 60 | 11.07.2015 | |
MFPW Heavyweight Title Four Way: Matthew Riddle defeats Punisher Martinez (c) and Clutch Adams and Mike Spanos - TITLE CHANGE !!! MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 61 | 27.06.2015 | |
MFPW Heavyweight Title: Punisher Martinez (c) defeats Matthew Riddle MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 62 | 25.04.2015 | |
MFPW Heavyweight Title: Matthew Riddle defeats Clutch Adams (c) by DQ MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 63 | 11.04.2015 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats Rhett Titus MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 64 | 28.03.2015 | |
Matthew Riddle defeats QT Marshall MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 65 | 14.02.2015 | |
Submission Match (Special Referee: X-Pac): Billy Damiana defeats Matthew Riddle MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 66 | 07.02.2015 | |
Matthew Riddle vs. Nick Comoroto - No Contest MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
