[1.0] "Big man who cant move he had some ok matches but now thanks to him, his only jobe was to stand there and be tall and wide, witch he was so job done? Had some not bad matches aginst better workers from the 60s wich save him from a zero but god."
[8.0] "In his early career he could put on a passable match. Later in his career, he became immobile and in some tag team matches, he would not even enter the match. Overall, he was more of an attaction than a wrestler. He grabbed some tag team gold, as he really would have struggled to put together programs required of a champion. I generally put attractions as a 6, but along with Monsoon, he's probably the best of the "fat guy" wrestlers. Better than Man Mountain Mike, The McGuire Twins, Man Mountain Campbell and Happy Humphrey, so I'll toss him a point. I'll add another point for longevity."
[0.0] "Oh come on. Who are some of you trying to fool? He sucked. Another non bumpin, do nothin' throwback to the carnival days when sometimes all you needed was girth. His massive drum body with it's frail tooth pick arms looked/will always look terrible. Some of these old timers are so over appreciated it's just asinine. Crap, pass, avoid."
[5.0] "Mostly treated as a spectacle wrestler, similar to Andre the Giant. However, he never had the presence that Andre had, considering his size, he was okay in the ring. RIP"
[6.0] "If Andre the Giant can have a 7. 00+ rating then so can Haystacks Callhoun. While he may not be the best big man to ever live, he could still move pretty well in the ring. He also played a good baby face and in all the matches I have watched of him the crowd was super behind him. Overall in my opinion better than Andre the Giant 6/10."
[10.0] "Before Andre the Giant came in to the scene, it was first Haystacks Calhoun who was a major draw among the big men in wrestling. His feud against Happy Humphrey will never be forgotten by old school fans. He may not be a great technical wrestler but was always fun to watch and he just really wants to give the crowd a good time. A true gentle giant Haystacks was."
[9.0] "Gigantischer Mensch, einer der ersten wahren Giganten im wrestling. Technisch natürlich nicht gut, aber dank Erscheinungsbild ein Wegbereiter für viele "Monster""
