[7.0] "improved immensely. great on the mic and in the ring. her last match with Jordyne grace showed just how far she's came and that she hasn't hit her peak/stride at all yet. excited to see more"
[8.0] "She is good, and can improve, I have seen her in RevPro were she was the Women's Champion and was good in the role, it seems like she is heading to Impact where she would be a solid addition."
[8.0] "A really solid wrestler who got better from her time in the UK. Very solid in-ring skills, good psychology, amazing character work, and a good promo. Overall, she's someone who should be placed at the top of whatever women's division she is put in"
[7.0] "I don't understand why Gisele has such a low score. She's an amazing wrestler and has been a great part of the Knockouts division since she joined. Her faction with Evans and Vidal has been a bit of a dud so far but I have hope that IMPACT can build Gisele and Evans into a solid part of the tag division."
[10.0] "Gisele Shaw is an excellent worker and a fantastic heel. I really enjoy her work in Impact, and hope she has a title run before the year is out. She's absolutely earned it. Realistically, I would probably rate her an 8, but I bumped it up to counteract a previous review which baselessly impugned her character and truthfulness."
[10.0] "I'm following Impact right now and this girl blew my mind. Beautiful, fast, good on the mic, and an excellent heel. Other than that his move-set is impressive. Made a great match with Trinity."
[7.0] "Getting a big push recently and I am really enjoying it. Shaw is a good athlete from what I have seen and I think she has Knockouts champion potential. Her match VS Mickie was pretty good aswell."
[7.0] "Very charismatic and surprisingly athletic, seen her hit some very impressive dives. Definitely deserves a higher rating though hasn't really had a chance to showcase herself on a major stage, mostly just working placeholder tv matches for Impact"
[5.0] "She has been seemingly hitting her strides in the UK wrestling scene over the past couple of years, but she still is far from perfect and needs the right opponent to provide a good match. The Quintessential Diva sure wrestles like one at times, but also lacks charisma and is trying to be UKs Charlotte."
[6.0] "The problem with Gisele Shaw actually is she's almost basically a copycat of Charlotte Flair from the outfit and attitude and that don't helps her at all. She's not bad in the ring, but she will always have the comparaison with Charlotte."
[5.0] "She is not catastrophic in the ring, when she is well matched with the right opponent she can give good matches, but she still has the same charisma as a stone."
[7.0] "Gisele has come a long way as a wrestler and is currently tearing up the UK indie scene. She has become quite the face of women's wrestling there, holding gold at both RevPro and PROGRESS. A recent series of matches with US independent standout Hyan are among some of her best work. They had a sensational 2 out of 3 falls match for RevPro in September."
[4.0] "She's not catastrophically bad in the ring, but even for her level of experience she isn't exactly impressive. At least she is showing some effort to improve her matches: hopefully this isn't just to land a contract with a big promotion and will lead to some acceptable matches. I haven't heard much of her promo material but so far she seems not have developed a proper character apart from being very good looking. Which so far is the only thing she has going for her."
[6.0] "Love the look of this kid! Easy on the eyes, not bad energy and decent skill for someone with less than 2 years experience. Haven't heard her mic skills so going only on what I have seen. Obviously still a little green so giving her the benefit of the doubt with a 6. 0 but I believe and hope she will get better and then can earn a higher rating."
[6.0] "Definitely a babe and not bad in the ring. Still a little green with less than 2 years experience but shows promise and hoping she will get better. Looking for her to win her first title soon. Giving her a 6. 0 for now but that will increase as she hopefully improves. Definitely keeping an eye on this kid and her career."
