| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 26.07.1999 |  |
Dark: Kurt Angle defeats Erin O'Grady WWF Shotgun Saturday Night - Dark Match @ Gund Arena in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 2 | 22.05.1999 |  |
Three Way Dance: Donovan Morgan defeats Boyce LeGrande and Erin O'Grady APW Mack Daddy's & Gigolo's - Event @ San Jose, California, USA |
| 3 | 17.04.1999 |  |
Three Way: Kurt Angle defeats Erin O'Grady and Steve Bradley PPW Memphis TV - TV-Show @ WMC-TV5 Studio in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 4 | 10.04.1999 | |
PPW Tag Team Title Two On One Handicap: Kid Wikkid (c) defeats Bulldog Raines & Erin O'Grady PPW Memphis TV - TV-Show @ WMC-TV5 Studio in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 5 | 03.04.1999 | |
PPW Young Guns Title: Steve Bradley (c) defeats Erin O'Grady PPW Memphis TV - TV-Show @ WMC-TV5 Studio in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 6 | 02.04.1999 | |
PPW Tag Team Title: Derrick King & Kid Wikkid defeat Erin O'Grady & Vic Grimes (c) by DQ PPW - House Show @ New Daisy Theatre in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 7 | 20.03.1999 | |
PPW Tag Team Title: Erin O'Grady & Vic Grimes defeat Derrick King & Kid Wikkid (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PPW Memphis TV - TV-Show @ WMC-TV5 Studio in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 8 | 27.02.1999 | |
Mick Tierney defeats Erin O'Grady PPW Memphis TV - TV-Show @ WMC-TV5 Studio in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 9 | 20.02.1999 | |
Lumberjack Strap: Erin O'Grady defeats Vic Grimes PPW Memphis TV - TV-Show @ WMC-TV5 Studio in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 10 | 13.02.1999 | |
Brian Christopher & Scott Taylor defeat Bulldog Raines & Erin O'Grady PPW Memphis TV - TV-Show @ WMC-TV5 Studio in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 11 | 12.02.1999 | |
Ladder: Vic Grimes defeats Erin O'Grady PPW You Ain't Seen Nothing Yet - House Show @ New Daisy Theatre in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 12 | 30.01.1999 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Vic Grimes PPW Memphis TV - TV-Show @ WMC-TV5 Studio in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 13 | 29.01.1999 | |
PPW Heavyweight Title Tournament First Round: Erin O'Grady defeats Vic Grimes PPW Heavyweight Title Tournament - House Show @ New Daisy Theatre in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 14 | 29.01.1999 | |
PPW Heavyweight Title Tournament Quarter Final: Baldo defeats Erin O'Grady PPW Heavyweight Title Tournament - House Show @ New Daisy Theatre in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 15 | 23.01.1999 | |
Bulldog Raines & Erin O'Grady defeat Baldo & Vic Grimes PPW Memphis TV - TV-Show @ WMC-TV5 Studio in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 16 | 16.01.1999 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Vic Grimes PPW Memphis TV - TV-Show @ WMC-TV5 Studio in Memphis, Tennessee, USA |
| 17 | 09.12.1998 |   |
Erin O'Grady, Flash Flanagan & Shawn Stasiak defeat Guido Andretti, Rod Steele & Vito Andretti NWA OVW TV - TV-Show @ Davis Arena in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
| 18 | 09.12.1998 | |
Dark: Bull Pain & Matt Bloom defeat Erin O'Grady & Shawn Stasiak (5:38) NWA OVW TV - Dark Match @ Davis Arena in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
| 19 | 08.12.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Jason Lee (12:01) NWA OVW - Event @ Louisville Gardens in Louisville, Kentucky, USA |
| 20 | 02.12.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady & Trailer Park Trash defeat Jason Lee & Rod Steele NWA OVW TV - TV-Show @ Davis Arena in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
| 21 | 01.12.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady vs. Jason Lee - Time Limit Draw (10:00) NWA OVW - Event @ Louisville Gardens in Louisville, Kentucky, USA |
| 22 | 25.11.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Steve Finley NWA OVW TV - TV-Show @ Davis Arena in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
| 23 | 24.11.1998 | |
Tarek The Great defeats Erin O'Grady (7:50) NWA OVW - Event @ Louisville Gardens in Louisville, Kentucky, USA |
| 24 | 17.11.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Chad Collyer (4:12) NWA OVW - Event @ Louisville Gardens in Louisville, Kentucky, USA |
| 25 | 30.10.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Chicano Flame #2 APW Halloween Hell 2 - The Final Garage Show - Event @ APW Garage in Hayward, California, USA |
| 26 | 17.10.1998 | |
Jason C. Clay, Rick Turner & Vinny Massaro defeat Chicano Flame, Erin O'Grady & Frank Murdoch APW Raising Hell In Highlands - Event @ Highlands, California, USA |
| 27 | 10.10.1998 | |
The Suicide Kid defeats Erin O'Grady APW Outbreak - Event @ APW Garage in Hayward, California, USA |
| 28 | 09.10.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady & Frank Murdoch vs. Jason C. Clay & Rick Turner - No Contest APW Return To The Large Garage - Event @ San Jose, California, USA |
| 29 | 25.09.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Chris Ward (6:27) APW Corporate Controversy - Event @ APW Garage in Hayward, California, USA |
| 30 | 12.09.1998 | |
Christopher Daniels & Michael Modest defeat Erin O'Grady & The Suicide Kid (19:10) APW Shooting For The Stars - Event @ APW Garage in Hayward, California, USA |
| 31 | 21.08.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Jimmy Ripp (5:14) APW Rumble In The Garage - Event @ APW Garage in Hayward, California, USA |
| 32 | 09.08.1998 | |
Christopher Daniels vs. Erin O'Grady - Time Limit Draw (15:00) APW Swiss Park Shootout 2 - Event @ Newark, California, USA |
| 33 | 24.07.1998 | |
Michael Modest defeats Erin O'Grady (18:47) APW We Wrestle - Event @ APW Garage in Hayward, California, USA |
| 34 | 10.07.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady vs. Robert Thompson - Time Limit Draw (30:00) APW Kicking Off The Cup - Event @ APW Garage in Hayward, California, USA |
| 35 | 28.06.1998 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Donovan Morgan, Erin O'Grady & Robert Thompson defeat Michael Modest, Tony Jones & Vinny Massaro [2:1] (18:28) APW Swiss Park Shootout - Event @ Newark, California, USA |
| 36 | 26.06.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Boyce LeGrande (14:13) APW Two Men...One Name - Event @ APW Garage in Hayward, California, USA |
| 37 | 12.06.1998 | |
Triple Threat: Tony Jones & Vinny Massaro defeat Boyce LeGrande & Robert Thompson and Donovan Morgan & Erin O'Grady (23:54) APW Triple Threat - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 38 | 30.05.1998 | |
Vinny Massaro defeats Erin O'Grady (13:27) APW Terra Nova Terror '98 - Event @ Pacifica, California, USA |
| 39 | 30.05.1998 | |
15 Man Battle Royal: Winner: Erin O'Grady (4:10) APW Terra Nova Terror '98 - Event @ Pacifica, California, USA |
| 40 | 29.05.1998 | |
Donovan Morgan defeats Erin O'Grady (12:51) APW Moondog On The Prowl - Event @ APW Garage in Hayward, California, USA |
| 41 | 16.05.1998 |  |
Tiger Ali Singh defeats Erin O'Grady WWA - Event @ Whitman, Massachusetts, USA |
| 42 | 15.05.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats The Vampire Warrior WWA - Event @ Lynn, Massachusetts, USA |
| 43 | 01.05.1998 | |
Vic Grimes defeats Erin O'Grady APW Grimes/O'Grady Send-Off - Event @ APW Garage in Hayward, California, USA |
| 44 | 03.04.1998 | |
Rick Turner defeats Erin O'Grady (3:38) APW Turn Back The Clock - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 45 | 28.03.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Rick Turner APW - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 46 | 27.03.1998 | |
APW Tag Team Title: Michael Modest & Tony Jones (c) defeat Donovan Morgan & Erin O'Grady (18:59) APW Return To The Large Garage - Event @ San Jose, California, USA |
| 47 | 14.03.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Tony Jones (19:45) APW March Madness - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 48 | 06.03.1998 | |
APW Tag Team Title: Michael Modest & Tony Jones (c) defeat Erin O'Grady & Vic Grimes (24:13) APW Wrestling Inc. - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 49 | 21.02.1998 | |
APW Universal Heavyweight Title: Robert Thompson (c) defeats Erin O'Grady (18:28) APW Who's The Man - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 50 | 30.01.1998 | |
Vic Grimes defeats Erin O'Grady (12:18) APW The Large Garage - Event @ San Jose, California, USA |
| 51 | 30.01.1998 | |
16 Man Battle Royal: Winner: Erin O'Grady APW The Large Garage - Event @ San Jose, California, USA |
| 52 | 20.01.1998 | |
Dark: Vic Grimes defeats Erin O'Grady (7:04) WWF Shotgun Saturday Night - Dark Match @ Recreation Hall in Davis, California, USA |
| 53 | 17.01.1998 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Donovan Morgan (16:34) APW Ultimate Jeopardy - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 54 | 03.01.1998 | |
Dic Grimes & Steve Rizzono defeat Erin O'Grady & Vic Grimes (21:41) APW He Shoots...He Scores - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 55 | 30.11.1997 |  |
Dark: Chris Chetti & Spike Dudley defeat Erin O'Grady & Paul Diamond ECW November To Remember 1997 - Dark Match @ Golden Dome in Monaca, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 56 | 28.11.1997 | |
Spike Dudley defeats Erin O'Grady (7:41) ECW - Event @ CYO Center in Trenton, New Jersey, USA |
| 57 | 15.11.1997 | |
Spike Dudley defeats Erin O'Grady ECW - Event @ High School Gym in Glasgow, Delaware, USA |
| 58 | 07.11.1997 | |
Justin Credible defeats Erin O'Grady ECW - Event @ Sports Palace in New Britain, Connecticut, USA |
| 59 | 03.10.1997 | |
Robert Thompson defeats Erin O'Grady (15:32) APW Night Of The Return Match - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 60 | 19.09.1997 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Michael Modest (12:56) APW Mystery Card - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 61 | 05.09.1997 | |
Erin O'Grady & Super Dragon defeat American Wild Child & Hellblazer (14:40) APW Sports Annihilation - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 62 | 29.08.1997 | |
Falls Count Anywhere Three Way Dance: Steve Rizzono defeats Erin O'Grady and Vic Grimes (19:41) APW 3-Way Apocalypse - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 63 | 15.08.1997 | |
APW Universal Heavyweight Title: Michael Modest (c) defeats Erin O'Grady (19:22) APW Mini Invasion - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 64 | 18.07.1997 | |
Falls Count Anywhere: Vic Grimes defeats Erin O'Grady (25:22) APW Falls Count Anywhere - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 65 | 04.07.1997 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Jason C. Clay (8:02) APW Catfight - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 66 | 04.07.1997 | |
12 Man Battle Royal: Winner: Erin O'Grady (22:19) APW Catfight - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 67 | 20.06.1997 | |
APW Universal Heavyweight Title Tournament First Round: Michael Modest defeats Erin O'Grady (13:47) APW Universal Heavyweight Title Tournament - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 68 | 07.06.1997 | |
APW Junior Heavyweight Title Three Way Dance: Chris Cole (c) defeats Donovan Morgan and Erin O'Grady (34:16) APW 3-Way Dance - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 69 | 31.05.1997 | |
APW Junior Heavyweight Title: Chris Cole (c) vs. Erin O'Grady - No Contest (11:23) APW Who Can Be Trusted - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 70 | 10.05.1997 | |
APW Junior Heavyweight Title: Chris Cole defeats Erin O'Grady (c) (10:05) - TITLE CHANGE !!! APW Modest Makes His Move - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 71 | 25.04.1997 | |
Chris Cole & Erin O'Grady defeat Chicano Flame & Jason C. Clay (7:46) APW Spartanfest '97 - Event @ Pinole, California, USA |
| 72 | 19.04.1997 | |
APW Junior Heavyweight Title: Erin O'Grady (c) defeats Chicano Flame (13:20) APW Bombers Chance At Revenge - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 73 | 29.03.1997 | |
APW Junior Heavyweight Title: Erin O'Grady (c) defeats Chris Cole APW Goodbye Dalton, Hello Murdoch - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 74 | 22.03.1997 | |
APW Junior Heavyweight Title Match (vakant): Erin O'Grady defeats Donovan Morgan (10:10) - TITLE CHANGE !!! APW Terra Nova Terror '97 - "O'Grady Returns Home" - Event @ Pacifica, California, USA |
| 75 | 08.03.1997 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Chris Cole (10:47) APW Return Of The Ragin Bull - Event @ Cupertino, California, USA |
| 76 | 07.03.1997 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Jason C. Clay (7:32) APW RIP JR Benson - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 77 | 15.02.1997 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Steve Rizzono (6:53) APW Havoc In The Ring - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 78 | 25.01.1997 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Boom Boom Comini (10:30) APW Doomsday - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 79 | 11.01.1997 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Frank Dalton by Count Out (9:47) APW Terror In Turloch - Event @ Turloch, California, USA |
| 80 | 04.01.1997 | |
APW Junior Heavyweight Title: Erin O'Grady defeats Super Diablo (c) by DQ (7:43) APW New Years Bash '97 - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 81 | 30.11.1996 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Chris Cole (8:14) APW Thanksgiving Thunder '96 - Event @ Lakeport, California, USA |
| 82 | 29.11.1996 |  |
Erin O'Grady vs. Steve Rizzono - Time Limit Draw BTW - Event @ Fremont, California, USA |
| 83 | 23.11.1996 | |
APW Tag Team Title Tournament First Round: Erin O'Grady & Mike Diamond defeat Bill Calhoun & Boom Boom Comini (11:05) APW Tag Title Tournament '96 - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 84 | 23.11.1996 | |
APW Tag Team Title Tournament Semi Final: Frank Dalton & Joe Applebaumer defeat Erin O'Grady & Mike Diamond (10:45) APW Tag Title Tournament '96 - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 85 | 02.11.1996 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Kwame Kamoze (6:36) APW Modest Crosses The Line - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 86 | 12.10.1996 | |
APW Junior Heavyweight Title Tournament Final Match (vakant): Super Diablo defeats Erin O'Grady (7:16) - TITLE CHANGE !!! APW Night Of Champions & Legends - Event @ Modesto, California, USA |
| 87 | 12.10.1996 | |
APW Junior Heavyweight Title Tournament First Round: Erin O'Grady defeats Chris Cole (4:29) APW Night Of Champions & Legends - Event @ Modesto, California, USA |
| 88 | 05.10.1996 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Jay Smooth APW - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 89 | 07.09.1996 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Bill Calhoun (8:59) APW Modesty & Mayhem - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 90 | 03.08.1996 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Boom Boom Comini (9:33) APW Border Patrol Crackdown - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 91 | 29.06.1996 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Chris Cole (12:34) APW Gym Warz - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 92 | 29.06.1996 | |
Erin O'Grady defeats Chris Cole APW - Event @ Hayward, California, USA |
| 93 | 04.05.1996 | |
Boom Boom Comini & Joe Applebaumer defeat Erin O'Grady & Rick Turner APW Tribute To A Legend - Event @ Ukiah, California, USA |
| 94 | 25.11.1995 |  |
La Migra I & La Migra II defeat Mexican Blanco & Super Diablo (Erin O'Grady) CMLL - Event @ Great Western Forum in Los Angeles, California, USA |
