Ash By Elegance

[2.0] "People can say she's athletic and a former bodybuilder, which is great and all... but it clearly isn't working for her in professional wrestling. She's just not good, she has 9 years of "experience" within the business but still doesn't understand basic fundamentals. I'm not hating on her as a person, because she does seem really nice and a lot of the pure hatred she gets from people online is pretty nuts. But if we're just talking about her as a professional wrestler, then yeah she's not good. WWE did at least try with her, but again she just doesn't really understand the business or just simply doesn't have what it takes to be a professional wrestler. Nothing wrong with that, a lot of us here don't have what it takes to be a professional wrestler neither, but this is 100% rating her as a wrestler in this business and she's just not good."

[7.0] "She has never been given the chance she deserves. There is so much we haven't seen from Ashley Sebera. Dana Brooke had all the potential in the world to go big time but nevermind that. Ash by Elegance is going to take TNA by storm and do big things! Hard to Kill was huge seeing her cross the line into the new era of TNA and I have no doubt that there will be big matches and much more to talk about when it comes to Ash by Elegance"

"I really don't like her and her fans. When she was booed by the fans, she would go to twitter and express his displeasure, while this is wrestling and she should know these things. Also, her fans supported him even though she had no special talent."

[4.0] "I'm honestly amazed that Dana Brooke has a following, I just don't get it. She's subpar at best, nothing about her stands out. She comes off to me as a "diva" era type performer than an actual wrestler that came up from NXT, which is odd since that's where she got her start in. Mediocre in ring wrestler and lacks charisma."

[7.0] "Sehr athletisch und schöne verschiedene Moves. Das einzige was sie davon abhält eine höhere Wertung zu bekommen ist ihre Unsauberkeiten die sie manchmal hat. Vielleicht liegt es aber auch daran, dass sie besser woanders sein sollte als WWE um ihr Talent zu beweisen."

[7.0] "Dana isn't bad as people make her out to be, This girl can work in the ring and actually has pretty looking move set. The company's refusal to book her seriously is what generates this forced hate towards her."

[1.0] "She struggles at the basic fundamentals of wrestling and can't sell. However, her offence is not 100% awful so she gets a point but she has never been a good worker."

[0.0] "She is not for wrestling at all, She can't wrestle, fans do not communicate with her at all, She is extremely boring and that is not good for tv at all, I think these are all the reasons why I give this woman 0."

[0.0] "Probably the worst woman wrestler in WWE today. She is bad in everything, horrible in the ring, can't work a proper match with a storytelling. even worse at promos especially as a face. Doesn't get any reaction from the crowd."

[4.0] "I've seen worse than Dana Brooke on the Divas Era. At least she is athletic enough to put on a fast pace match, but not good enough to deliver a memorable performance. Yeah, she works hard, she has a great physique, but she is not that good of a worker, doesn't have a gimmick and is a charisma vacuum."

[5.0] "I only give this rating because WWE hasn't used her correctly. I remember her days as Ashley Sebera on the female bodybuilding circuit and remember being impressed by her physique. When WWE signed her, I was thrilled because I thought she could be the next Sable along with actually caring which was a quality the actual Sable seemed to lack. Sadly, ever since her debut, WWE has held back what she could actually do if used well. I keep hoping that those days are approaching. Until then, I put her right in the middle"

[2.0] "Dana Brooke is just not good in the ring or on the mic, and isn't charismatic at all. Like Alexa and Carmella, she was called up too early, but they are at least good on the mic."

[4.0] "Dana Brooks is alright in the ring and on the mic but does not compete with some of her peers in that respect. As a fan you want to get behind her because of her passion and work ethic and she has improved greatly. Good lower mid card woman but I doubt she ever is a true star in WWE."

[2.0] "I mean she is just bad on the ring and on the mic and has nothing to make her stand out. The defontion of the kind of worker that should not be on a nationl stage"

[8.0] "Dana deserves more than a 6 without a doubt. She is good, uses difficult moves and has improved enormously since 2018. He did an amazing job when he was tagged by Mandy Rose and unfortunately he was forgotten after that. I hope that now she can overcome herself more without that ridiculous title they just disabled."

[4.0] "I must say that I have nothing against her, but as a fighter I have never liked her. Although it is true, she could have a good way in the WWE but it is not that they have not put on their part."

[3.0] "I really want to be her fan, but there is nothing to be a fan of. She has some kind of presentation as a strong woman, does SOMETHING with 24/7 "Title", not sure what it is, but its something. She was kind of ok, when she was Charlottle's sidekick. Just pretty mediocre in all that she does, and shows no sign of progess. I like her flexing."

[2.0] "The only thing about her that ever impressed me is how she managed to somehow avoid getting released."

[4.0] "I feel bad for Dana because she's someone who's put in a lot of work over the last 8 years to try to become a good wrestler, and she's clearly not someone who wusses out or is lazy with her training given her extensive match record. That said, I don't think she's ever been good and a lot of her best matches are her bumping and selling for more competent acts while she works as a basic cocky heel, which she does fine enough in. WWE have tried to give her some experience in that field but she's hit a wall in terms of progression and seems to be content being in the undercard, which suits her a lot better than trying to be more of a main eventish kind of deal. She's not....very good but manages to function as a decent undercard worker that can do short matches and whatnot. She's not good on the mic through by far. Not good, but I wouldn't say she was dreadful either."

[2.0] "She's athletic I will give her that. However, she's bland in her promos and on the mic, doesn't have much charisma, either as a face or a heel and isn't good in the ring. She's someone that should be learning in NXT and continuing building her character. WWE called her up too soon and then kept her there. She should have been sent down to work on things because as an athlete she's good. But nothing else is there. Her 24/7 program has been entertaining to some degree though so maybe a point for that but she's one of the weaker superstars on the WWE roster."

[2.0] "Lol. What else can I say. Just lol. She's a nonentity in WWE. She's bad in the ring and basically has no character. She's athletic but can't apply it to anything. She's another product of the Divas era."

[4.0] "She has a cool move or two that she uses regularly and maybe one or two cool moves she uses infrequently. Her character is so plain though."

[6.0] "Good in the ring and looks phenomenal these days but lacks a direction in character and can not cut a convincing babyface promo to save her life."

[2.0] "Dana could have turned out to become a decent wrestler, who could have been a solid hand in the midcard. However, in her 5+ years on the roster, she has barely improved in ring, isnt a good promo and her character is dead. Now she's just a jobber and will almost certainly never get out of that hole."

[6.0] "I am a huge advocate for Dana Brooke, but I can still admit she isn't the best. She's very athletic, but that's all she really has. She isn't bad at anything, but she doesn't stand out either. Contrary to popular belief, she has improved over her career. Her movements are more crisp and her selling has improved. Overall though, she's decent at everything but doesn't stand out at all. I would have loved to see her reunite with Charlotte, but that ship seems to have sailed."

[4.0] "I think if Dana got the chance to show it my opinion of her could improve but she never got a substantial enough push for me to judge. With what she gave us, she is certainly athletic and her Titus Worldwide run was perhaps the most fun and notable thing she did along with her alliance with Emma on NXT. She's also not shy about taking huge bumps, which I appreciate and could honestly be a good selling point for her. However, her athleticism is yet to result in any notable good matches. I'd say she's a tag team division main stay if she (and the titles) remain in WWE for a lot longer, and perhaps there she can find a bit of success, but as a singles competitor I don't see her doing much."

[4.0] "She is not bad, but she is just boring. I don't remeber any particularly good match she was a part of."

[4.0] "I think she was at her best when she was more Emma's manager in NXT. Other than that really bland and nothing special."

[3.0] "Dana Brooke ist sehr athletisch, aber das macht noch keine gute Wrestlerin aus. Was man ihr zu gute halten kann ist, dass sie sich versucht zu verbessern und es tatsächich ernst meint akzeptiert zu werden, sei es nur mit kleineren Erfolgen. Das macht sie ein Stück weit sympathisch. Leider sind die Verbesserungen nur von minimaler Natur. In der Divas Era wäre sie wohl besser aufgehoben gewesen."

[2.0] "Nicht wirklich gut am Mic und im Ring. Nur eine Mitläuferin in der Womens Division. Sehe leider nicht viel gutes bei ihr."

[3.0] "Dana Brooke has a great personality and a lot of charisma, as well as being a pretty good talker, but she's pretty awful in the ring, and hasn't really improved at all since she has been on the main roster. I have been most entertained by her when she was paired with Emma on NXT and when she was with Apollo Crews and Titus O'Neil in Titus Worldwide. She showed a lot of character during those times. I know she added a Batista Bomb and Swanton Bomb to her moveset, but she still loves around like she's just learning how to wrestle, and that mini push she had at the early part of the year a little after Covid hit didn't make sense."

[6.0] "Dana Brooke has improved a lot since she first joined the main roster. Though she is still figuring out who she is as a wrestler, her move set and mic skills have evolved. Especially loved her role in 2020's MitB match."

[1.0] "Am Mic und im Ring leider unzumutbar. Besitzt für mich leider kaum etwas, um einen Spot im Roster recht zufertigen."

[6.0] "Ich finde Dana Brooke mittlerweile ziemlich solide und sehe sie unter allen Frauen im WWE Main Roster mit am liebsten, was vor allem daran liegt, dass sie inzwischen den ultimativen Underdog ausstrahlt. Im Ring hat sie sich ziemlich verbessert und ist wirklich sehr athletisch und kann sogar gute Highflying moves zeigen. Was das In Ring Work angeht würde ich sie wohl zur besseren Hälfte des Main Rosters zählen (definitiv vor z. B. Carmella, Shayna Baszler, Mandy Rose, Lacey Evans etc. ). Ein perfektes Gesamtpaket ist sie sicherlich nicht, aber irgendwie hat sie es dennoch geschaft over zu kommen und ich würde mir wünschen, dass sie irgendwann mal einen großen Moment bekommen wird, auch wenn es für einen großen Push wohl nicht reichen wird."

[6.0] "Oh ja, auch sie macht merkliche Fortschritte. Während sie am Mic nach wie vor eindeutig die schlechteste Frau im ganzen Roster ist (Wie kann man nur so gekünstelt und auswendig gelernt sprechen? ), verbessert sie sich stetig im Ring. Respekt dafür, dass sie als Erste mit Asuka in den Ring steigt und erstmal die volle Packung bekommt. UPDATE: Das bestätigt sich alles weiterhin, auch wenn sie mittlerweile deutlich besser im Ring ist."

[6.0] "She was very good in the role as the protege of Emma (Tenille Dashwood) in EnD. You could feel their chemistry and Dana improved a lot with the help of Emma. When they broke EnD up and made Dana the protege of Charlotte, it didn't work as well and Dana had some weak showings. Since then Dana's usually (or not usually used) on the under-midcard. She's charismatic, in-ring okay nowadays."

[4.0] "Currently, word going around is that Dana is putting in a tremendous amount of work. She spends most of her off time at the Performance Center and is really working to get noticed. I certainly respect that. But even that considered, she's low on the totem pole currently. Never seemed to flow well between the ropes & her character just feels like "random girl #12". I think she could have used a few more years in developmental & in NXT."

[6.0] "As of today, Dana Brooke is 31 years old, which is the age that most wrestlers start to realize their potential through their work inside and outside of the ring. To her credit, Brooke is a fantastic athlete, has a great look, and is a great seller for her opponents in the ring. But, she has yet to break that glass ceiling in the Women's Division because she still lacks experience and needs more seasoning. However, for the last three years, she has been paying her dues by training regularly at the Performance Center, showing up early, setting up the ring, and working on her craft in the ring. I am rooting for Dana's efforts to pay off at Money In The Bank so she can hopefully show off her improvement."

[6.0] "Although Dana could use a lot of work, I think a lot of her flaws could be concealed by using a more power based moveset, or going back to train at the PC for another six months. She has a good look, sells well and at this point has more marketability than a lot of her contemporaries."

[5.0] "Dana has improved a lot over the past year. Her in-ring work is still not quite up to par but she definitely has athletic ability so it looks like she might get somewhere soon."

[7.0] "Klar Dana Brooke ist nicht die allerbeste Wrestlerin im Roster und klar ist sie immer wieder für einen Botch gut, aber man merkt ihr an, sie hat den Willen und auch das Potential sich zu verbessern, um wieder vom Ende der RAW-Woman's Division wegzukommen und endlich auch mal die Titelchancen zu bekommen, die sie auch so verdient hat, denn ihre fehlenden In-Ring Skills macht sie durch ihr super Charisma und auch durch ihr gutes Mic-Work wieder weg. Dennoch zählt Dana Brooke mit zu meinen absoluten Favoriten in der WWE."

[7.0] "Dana Brooke is the most underrated female athlete in WWE. With exceptional body plasticity and amazing physical abilities, she never jumped above the matches of low-card and fought with wrestlers like Alicia Fox and Nia Jax. Good on the MIC, average in the ring, and having an imposing appearance, sooner or later, she's must get a strong place in the mid-card or tag team division at least. Also I like her musical theme which suits her very well and sounds so brutal."

[6.0] "Dana is an ok wrestler she could of been great if she was kept in nxt longer she is no doubt the worst booked woman on the roster which is a shame because tamina and nia aren? t as good as her yet they are getting pushed and shoved down our throats"

[4.0] "Dana is one of the first few major victims of NXT workers being called up too early. For her first 2 years, she was god awful both in the ring and on the mic yet they had her in the main event of the women's division as CHarlottes sidekick. Fast forward to present day and she's still not very good but she's improved and is the definition of "adequate. " I do think that she gets some undeserved hate due to her first few years but you can tell she WANTS to get better and improve. She's only been wrestling for 4 years so maybe in another 4 years, I'll be able to raise this rating!"

[2.0] "Schlechte Wrestlerin und als "Managerin" sogar noch schlechter. Und die ganzen Schönheits-OPs machen die Sache auch nicht besser..."

[4.0] "She was getting better down in nxt and then they stalled that growth by calling her up. Injury didnt help and now shes just not very good. I still like her a lot more than most on the main roster but she has her set spot now with no signs of improvement"

[5.0] "Im Ring ist sie sicherlich nicht besonders. Immer mal wieder für einen Botch gut allerdings recht athletisch, sodass sie in kurzen Matches oder Tag Matches ertragbar ist aber sicherlich nicht für eine Karriere im Singlesbereich bestimmt. Im Ring würde ich ihr 3 Punkte geben. Charisma ist bei ihr zwar nicht in Übermaßen aber absolut vorhanden. Sie zieht nicht die krassen Reaktionen aber kann durchaus unterhalten, besonders in ihrer derzeitigen Rolle bei Titus worldwide und deshalb 6 Punkte in dem Bereich. Micwork wirkte am Anfang holprig aber wurde immer besser und inzwischen ist das absolut anständig und zu ihrer Rolle passend und daher auch hier 6 Punkte. Insgesamt 5 Punkte. Ich finde in ihre jetzige Rolle passt sie gut, da sie besser im Entertainmentbereich als im sportlichen Bereich ist. obwohl letzteres auch nach nicht einmal vier Jahren im Ring noch kommen kann."

[6.0] "Not very good technically, but really athletic and have some nice moves. A lot of potential, ruined by the WWE."

[4.0] "Not good enough anymore. During her time in NXT, she seemed to be improving at a decent rate, but once she got that injury on the main roster, that was it for her. She regressed and earned the name of "Dana Botch" - and "Dana Bitch" given how insecure she seemed when she responded to someone posting a gif of her botching. Since her failed face turn, she hasn't been doing much on TV, and frankly, that's for the best."

[7.0] "Dana really gets a tough time of it for some reason. While she can certainly be botchy, she posseses some promising tools with her physique, drive and athleticism. I also think she has some good charisma and character value. I enjoyed her head-patting NXT run and thought her best use was at ringside for Emma vs Asuka. Another NXT run is something I think that can bring her out of her current rut into some long-term gain, especially with the vast amount of fresh talent that division posseses in 2017."

[1.0] "I am not totally shit on her. She was called up too early when she wasn't ready. She showed some potential in nxt, but wwe rushed her to the main roster. She just sucked, she didn't even know how to put the leg on the rope. Really ? . Terrible in ring work and mic work. Wwe used to be high on her when they teased she and charlotte could break up all the time, but it seemed like they already gave up with her."

[4.0] "Damals in NXT als the Next Big Thing wochenlang mit Vignetten gehypt, ist sie mittlerweile kaum noch im TV zu sehen und am ganz unteren Ende der Nahrungskette angekommen. Natürlich ist Dana nicht toll im Ring, aber sie wrestled auch erst seit 3 Jahren, die Athletik und das Potenzial sich zu verbessern hätte sie allemal. Zudem durchaus charismatisch und bei Breaking Ground recht sympathisch gewesen. Glaube zwar nicht, dass sie nochmal ne Chance erhält, aber verdient hätte sie diese meiner Meinung nach schon."

[10.0] "2016 is the year of Dana Brooke ! Her WWE debut feel great , she had a great entrance and attitude in the ring and selling correclty the moves ! Her finisher is painfull. She had the charisma to be a future WWE Women's Champion! She looks sometimes Beth Phoenix , that's nostalgic !"

[3.0] "Sehe sie mittlerweile eher als loud mouth-Managerin denn als Wrestlerin. In NXT war sie durchwachsen, der call up inkl. den dominanten Siege über Becky wirkten in Summe fast albern. Sie hat nichts Besonders und zieht eigentlich keine Reaktionen in ihrer Rolle als "besty" für Charlotte. Der Turn wurde also überfällig wahrgenommen, auch da zog sie keinerlei Reaktionen. Im Ring wirkt sie immer noch grün, hat zwar interessante Ansätze, aber kann daraus leider nichts machen. Langfristig fehlt hier komplett die Perspektive."

[3.0] "Eine unterdurchschnittliche Wrestlerin, deren Gimmick ziemlich nervig ist. Vielleicht kann sie sich noch steigern. Bei der kurzen Erfahrung die sie mitbringt kann sie sich auch noch zum besseren entwickeln. [Update 11. 10. 2015]: Aufgrund ihrer Verbesserungen + 1 Punkt, ihr Gimmick ist mittlerweile solide. [Update 24. 04. 2017] Leider aktuell wieder in der Irrelevanz angekommen. Daher wieder DREI PUNKTE!"

[4.0] "Has a bit of charisma to her and a good look, but ring work is still severely lacking; gets frequent opportunities to wrestle some of the best female performers in the world on WWE's flagship show and falls flat every time."

[2.0] "Dana Brooke is a product of bad timing. Originally brought up as the crony of Emma, an injury to Emma caused her to be without purpose on the main roster. Brooke then became saddled with Charlotte, and this led to her being overexposed as a green worker with a lack of charisma. In Brooke's defense, she hasn't developed a character outside of "champion's whipping girl" and that has stunted her. Brooke has a great physique and seems to know how to play a good heel but she needs to improve as worker, namely her clumsiness to really find her niche in 2017."

[2.0] "Kommt bei mir persönlich einfach nicht an, in erster Linie ist ihr InRing skill einfach zu schlecht fürs Main Rooster. Am Mic ebenfalls schlecht. Hätte noch mind. 1 Jahr in NXT gehört. mit viel arbeit evt einmal eine durchschnittliche Wrestlerin, aber mehr wohl nie"

[4.0] "A shining example of a talent called up too soon. Her time in NXT wasn't anything outstanding, but there was a lot of promise and raw material waiting to be molded into something great. Her match with Asuka is a good example, but Asuka can make just about anyone look good. Ever since her call up, she's just kind of floundered around and hasn't really improved much. She makes for a good heel, but just isn't given the chance. Then again, maybe all she's meant to be is someone else's lackey."

[6.0] "I'm getting disappointed, she has great heel work, good mic work and I think her moveset is fine, but her greenness on the main roster is annoying."

[4.0] "Dana Brooke is definitely a rookie, however, for someone who trained for less than a year before her debut, I am impressed. She isn't a strong competitor in terms of in-ring acumen, but there is room for growth, and she has shown that she can improve. She also has a lot of natural charisma, and can get a response from an audience on the fly. All in all, a work in progress, but she definitely has the potential."

[1.0] "It's obvious that they see her as a big star, but let's be honest... This chick isn't very good. In fact, astonishingly, she's gotten worse since my comment was first made. I had to lower my rating because quite frankly every time she goes out there, I have a stronger urge to change the channel than ever."

[3.0] "Close to a year of being on the main roster and nothing of significance has happened with Dana Brooke. Just watched her arm wrestling match with Bayley this past Monday. Ugh. Painful to endure watching. 3 out of 10 and I'm being generous."

[0.0] "Maybe I'm being harsh on Dana because she's inexperienced. That still doesn't change the fact that she's on the main roster, and therefore should be judged as a main roster performer. All I have to say is she was brought up WAY too early. Can't wrestle, can't act, can't talk, can't even walk or run convincingly. The only match she's had worth watching was against Asuka at Takeover Respect, but then again she was against Asuka, in her debut no less. Definite 0 so far. UPDATE: And after that ridiculous botch on Raw I know longer feel any sympathy towards this idiot. Send her back down to NXT. By this point I wish I could give her a minus rating. It's insulting that she's as HIGH as 4. 32"

[3.0] "Dana ist noch sehr sehr grün im Ring, das macht ihre Matches durch schlechtes Timing und durch das Verpeilen von einfachsten Grundlagen echt schlimm. Man hat sie viel zu früh ins Main Roster befördert. Einen Punkt gibt es für die Athletik (1/10). Am Mic ist das ausreichend (4/10). Ausstrahlung ist sehr solide (7/10). Charismatisch ist sie leider kaum (1/10). Insgesamt sind das dann 3, 25 von 10 Punkten - 'nicht ausreichend'."

[8.0] "She was getting better but then the injury has hurt her development but what we seen so far isn't bad. She is already better Eva Marie which is a very good thing."

[10.0] "Sie ist einfach nur HOT HOT HOT ;) Im ring ist sie ganz ok Charisma hat sie auch nicht wirklich. Aber dafür das sie erst 1Jahr aktiv ist ist sie schon echt klasse. Mein kommentar ist zu kurz also muss ich noch irgenedwas schreiben."

[1.0] "This girl simply needs Jesus. I thought we were supposed to be having a "women's revolution" in the WWE? Not with this chick, you aren't. The only thing she's good for is performing in a squash match, and maybe not even that. She can't sell properly nor hit a simple dropkick without botching. I've seen better trampoline wrestlers."

[0.0] "One of the absolute worst wrestlers currently active, right up there with Eva Marie in terms of being so bad it's comical to watch. It's almost like Brooke is addicted to botching, especially noticeable in atrocious selling and poor timing. She also has no grasp on ring psychology and talks way too much during matches, even for a heel, to the point that it becomes distracting for the viewer. I can't believe this Bridgette B lookalike is on the main roster ahead of women like Bayley and Asuka who blow her out of the water in every conceivable category. An absolute sham if you ask me."

[7.0] "Ich finde sie macht ihren Job gut dafür dass sie erst 1 Jahr dabei ist. Sie ist wirklich eine gute Heel. klar, im Ring noch verbesserungswürdig aber sie ist wie gesagt erst ein jahr dabei. Ich mag sie einfach irgendwie"

[7.0] "I know she is very green, but she is a very good phrospect of future. Physically gifted. I think the bookers did great matching her with Charlotte in order to get more experience on the main roster. If she works hard, I am sure that she could have a bright future in WWE."

[6.0] "Ich denke man sollte Dana Brooke noch nicht bewerten. Sie ist nicht mal ein Jahr aktiv, macht aber einen relatvien ordentlichen Job wesshalb ich die schlechte Wertung nicht ganz nachvollziehen kann. Also von mir noch keine Wertung. EDIT: Inzwischen finde ich Dana echt solide. Sie ist absolut brauchbar im Ring, bringt die Heel Bi*ch perfekt rüber und kann Promos halten. Sie hat eine menge Potential und hat sich in ihrer kurzen zeit in der WWE stark gebessert."

[1.0] "Bei Nxt fand ich sie noch ganz okay aber jetzt wo sie im Main Roster ist sieht man natürlich mehr Matches von ihr.. Da bekommt man erst mal richtig mit, wie viel sie botcht. Sie muss sich noch stark verbessern."

[3.0] "Why on earth did Dana Brooke debut so early? She's definitely got potential as a powerhouse -- something the women's division doesn't have a ton of. But she's still very raw in the ring and forced/unconvincing on the microphone. Granted, she's not as awful as some women the company has recently employed, but Dana definitely isn't up to the standards of the rest of the NXT era graduates. This is a rating which could improve with time, but for now Brooke has proved herself little other than clumsy and inept at putting together matches."

[3.0] "She looked promising coming out of the gate on the main roster, but has quickly shown she's not ready to have a match longer than 3 minutes let alone be heavily featured given the abundance of talented women they have on the payroll."

[8.0] "Sie ist einfach hot hot hot. Man hat Spaß sie anzuschauen. Außerdem halte ich sie ringin-technisch für noch stark entwicklungsfähig."

[2.0] "She is not good at all in the ring. She does not even have a real gimmick right now. She looks like a frickin stripper all the time as well. Really all she has done is been a body guard for Emma and Charlotte. She needs to get better in the ring, get a damn character, and actually try to put on an entertaining match for once."

[6.0] "Has potential to develop and has a good heel persona, but still a long way from being ready for the main roster of WWE."

[5.0] "Has the physical tools and charisma needed to be a great heel someday. She's improved by leaps and bounds in a short amount of time. Started very raw and is now respectable. If she continues to improve at this rate, she'll be a 7 or 8 within a year or two."

[5.0] "She has come a long way since she debuted. I would have given her a 1 after her first two months. She's really hot, and has the looks that WWE wants. I am a bit weird out when she flexes though; I get you're strong, but you're not a man. I barely work out and I have bigger muscles than you do and hell I'm 18. Aside from that, she is still green and needs a lot of work, but at end of this year, I am expecting her to be a 7 in my book."

[4.0] "Coming to WWE with no prior wrestling experience, Dana Brooke is still very much a developmental prospect. To her credit, she has worked hard to improve since her debut and has grown in leaps and bounds in terms of in-ring fundamentals, and the company has wisely paired her up with more experienced wrestlers both as opponents and partners to help her learn. She certainly has the kind of look WWE loves for their Divas, and time will tell if her in-ring abilities will continue to grow to the point that she can headline NXT's women's division or move on to the main roster."

[6.0] "Dana is improving and getting better in the ring. Her character work is improving far faster and she is a heat machine. Teaming with Emma probably helped speed the process that Brooke has undertaken. It will be interesting to see how far Dana grows under the learning tree of Emma. Her time in NXT is paying off and she is doing well for herself and has a lot of potential to keep maturating as a performer."

[6.0] "As others have noted Dana Brooke has improved since her debut, which is exactly what I hope to see from homegrown NXT talent. You could argue she wasn't ready for TV when she arrived but it's engaging to see a marked development through televised matches."

[7.0] "What I enjoy about Dana Brooke is her quick improvement in the ring, and outside. Her unfortunate debut match against Leva Bates was unsurprisingly sloppy, but week by week she's been stepping out and showing off. I also find her villainous character tics very amusing."

[9.0] "I believe she has improved a little bit. Her match with Asuka showed that she belongs in NXT. I do think that she can definitely get better. When I saw her on Breaking Ground on monday I found respect towards her that she does to succeed in the wresting business and I do believe she can."

"Sie fair zu bewerten geht natürlich noch nicht. Aber man kann trotzdem schon mal abklopfen wie der aktuelle Sympathiewert ist. Und ich mag sie ehrlich gesagt nicht. Aus zwei Gründen: Erstens bin ich kein Fan davon wenn die WWE mir versucht eine/n Worker mir unbedingt "aufdrücken" will. Und das versucht man bei ihr. Viel Hype und natürlich die Berichterstattung das sie bei einem Bodybuilding Contest die WWE repräsentiert hat. Erinnert schon ein wenig an "handpicked" und "Chosen One". // Update 22. 10. 15 Nun, ich bin nicht zu stolz zuzugeben wenn mich etwas getäuscht hat und im Umkehrschluss positiv überrascht. Man erkennt deutliche Schritte nach vorne und sie scheint - wie nahezu alle bei NXT - den Willen zu besitzen sich auch wirklich nach vorne zu entwickeln. Derzeit finde ich sie sogar unterhaltsam. Auf eine Bewertung verzichte ich dennoch. Sollte die Entwicklung weiterhin so positiv verlaufen, dürfte aber nichts gegen eine 3 mit Hang zur 4 Sprechen. Ich könnte mir sogar vorstellen das sie innerhalb eines Jahres besser ist als manch eine Dame die schon im Main Roster eingesetzt wird (Stichwort Bellas)."

[5.0] "Im Gegensatz zu einer Eva Marie erkennt man bei ihr den Willen wirklich an sich zu arbeiten und das Match gegen Asuka war von ihrer Seite aus so übel wie erwartet auch nicht. Und dafür ist NXT ja doch eigentlich da. Von jedem Rookie bereits am ersten Tag Top-Leistungen zu erwarten finde ich dann doch ein wenig ungerecht. Und mal ehrlich: da gibt es vor allem im Main Roster schlimmere Ressourcen-Verschwendungen, die zwar schon über fünf Jahre (! ) dabei sind, aber trotzdem im Ring nicht wirklich viel können."

[6.0] "A rapidly improving heel worker. Has the popular girl at school thing going for her, and gaining steam in the ring too. Better than Emma."

[2.0] "Dana Brooke is an obvious rookie. She's a bit clumsy in the ring and has a very limited move-set, but has a good finisher. Her mic skills are awful. Her promos all sound like she's reading off cue cards and her accent can be really off-putting. Her physique and the "Total Diva" heel character is really her biggest positive (It also doesn't hurt that she's teaming with Evil Emma). Dana has potential and I feel like in a year or two she could really be a useful addition to the women's division."

[5.0] "Bis jetzt Mittelmäßig bis schlecht, aber hey! es ist NXT. Hier ist alles möglich! Ich denke sie hat potenzial und kann sich steigern. Sie ist noch ziemlich jung und unerfahren und hat noch nen großen Weg vor sich. Kein Wrestler wurde perfekt geboren ;)"

[7.0] "Im Gegensatz zu Eva Marie sehe ich in Dana Brooke von Zeit zu Zeit immer mehr Potenzial. Die Frau strengt sich wirklich an und meiner Meinung nach kann man das auch sehen. Die Dame ist jetzt nicht einmal ein volles Jahr aktiv und ist bereits in der Lage, sich (für ihre Verhältnisse) schnell zu steigern. Sie hat einen eigenen Look, mit dem Bodybuilding einen sportlichen Hintergrund und Charisma. Wenn sie weitermacht und hoffentlich bald die Outfits ändert, haben wir bald die nächste Durchstarterin. Bislang noch ein Rohdiamant mit Potenzial."

[0.0] "Grauenhafte In-Ring präsenz, botcht jeden 3. Move und alles andere als eine brauchbare Ausstrahlung. Tag-Team mit Eva Marie wäre ein Traum, da wäre der NXT-Ausschuss mal versammelt..."

"Sie wirkt auf mich wie eine eventuelle Nachfolgerin für die gute Beth Phoenix (blond und muskulös). Habe bisher nur ein Match von ihr gesehen und von daher keine Grundlage sie zu bewerten. Ich bin mal gespannt wie sie sich so macht, weil sie noch ganz am Anfang ihrer Karriere steht. Potential ist jedenfalls vorhanden. EDIT: Hinzufügen sollte ich noch, dass sie mit ihrer minimalen Erfahrung schon besser ist als Kolleginnen die länger dabei sind, deswegen bin ich gespannt was sie noch zeigen wird."

[3.0] "also das, was ich bisher von ihr gesehen habe, war nicht gut. Wenn man eine Diva so bewirbt, dann muss sie auch liefern können, was sie nicht kann. Schon das erste match von ihr war grausam. 80% der Aktionen von ihr waren gebotcht (und es gab nicht allzu viele). Danach machte sie auch keinen guten Eindruck wie ich finde..."

[2.0] "Bis jetzt hat sie nur unglaubwürdige Backstage-Promos gehalten und auch die In-Ring Skills überzeugen nicht. Da muss noch viel Übung ran, bevor sie sich richtig in der Divas Division von NXT zurecht gefunden hat."

[2.0] "Good finisher. After that, Dana is just a rookie, her ring skills need more work and her mannerisms can be toned down."

[5.0] "Bin noch skeptisch bei ihr. Dennoch habe ich das Gefühl, dass aus ihr eine neue Kaitlyn werden könnte. Diese war anfangs auch nicht die beste Wrestlerin, aber konnte sich immer mehr steigern. Ich glaub, diesen ehrgeiz hat Dana auch."

[0.0] "Well, it is pretty unfair to judge someone after one match, but Dana can always improve, forcing me to edit my rating. So far she looks horrible (and no, NXT at this point can't be considered as developmental, so she gets no bonus points from me)"