| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 11.01.2020 |  |
Dave Bentley defeats Angus O'Toole PWR Payback - Event @ Saga Club in Erie, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 2 | 09.11.2019 | |
Angus O'Toole defeats Sebastian Braun PWR The People's Choice - Event @ Saga Club in Erie, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 3 | 12.10.2019 | |
Three Way: Marcus Knight defeats Angus O'Toole and Anthony Musso PWR - Event @ Saga Club in Erie, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 4 | 10.11.2018 | |
Angus O'Toole defeats David Bentley PWR - Event @ Saga Club in Erie, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 5 | 23.07.2016 |  |
Shane Matthews defeats Angus O'Toole MAW Anniversary Show 2016 - Event @ St. Francis Xavier Cabrini Parish in Lovain, Ohio, USA |
| 6 | 16.11.2013 |  |
Drake Andrews defeats Angus O'Toole MPW Survive Or Surrender - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 7 | 19.10.2013 | |
Three On One Handicap Gauntlet: Angus O'Toole defeats The Fellowship (Mr. Friday Night, Scott Prodigy & Tristan Tyler) MPW Brawl-O-Ween - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 8 | 17.08.2013 | |
30 Man Battle Royal: Joey Diamante and Shawn Blaze defeat ??? and ??? and ??? and ??? and ??? and ??? and ??? and ??? and ??? and ??? and ??? and Adam Meekins and Andre Kanan Alexander and Angus O'Toole and Brandon X and Chase Aaryons and Ethan Wright and Kip Paige and Marcus Knight and Reverend Joseph C. Slick and Ryan Burke and Ryan Whitten and Scott Prodigy and Senor Sanchez and Seth Allen and Super Nerd and The Aftermath and The Bouncer MPW Rumble By The Lake - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 9 | 25.05.2013 | |
Chase 4 The Case Qualifying: Scott Prodigy defeats Angus O'Toole MPW Chase 4 The Case - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 10 | 11.05.2013 | |
Dark: Jimi The High-Flyin' Hippie defeats Angus O'Toole PWR - Dark Match @ St. John’s Conference & Banquet Center in Girard, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 11 | 11.05.2013 | |
PWR Wild Card Title Suicide Six Pack: Frankie Feathers (c) vs. Andre Kanan Alexander vs. Angus O'Toole vs. Johnny Gun vs. Kaiser Stern vs. Marcus Knight - No Contest PWR - Event @ St. John’s Conference & Banquet Center in Girard, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 12 | 20.04.2013 | |
Joey Vincent Martini defeats Angus O'Toole MPW Breakthrough - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 13 | 13.04.2013 | |
20 Man Rampage Rumble 2013: Lumberjack LeRoux defeats Aaron Draven and Andre Kanan Alexander and Angus O'Toole and Asylum and Bennett Cole and Bill Collier and Brandon Thurston and Brian DeVille and Frankie Feathers and James Santel and Jamie Scott and Jeremiah Bradley and Jimi The High-Flyin' Hippie and Marcus Knight and Rex Atkins and Robbie Reckless and Rocky Reynolds and Shane Taylor and Troy Buchannan PWR - Event @ Saga Club in Erie, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 14 | 23.03.2013 | |
Scott Prodigy defeats Angus O'Toole MPW Press Your Luck - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 15 | 09.03.2013 | |
Angus O'Toole defeats Jeremiah Bradley PWR - Event @ Saga Club in Erie, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 16 | 23.02.2013 | |
Mr. Friday Night defeats Angus O'Toole MPW In Like A Lion - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 17 | 26.01.2013 | |
The Forsaken (Bennett Cole & Jimmy Fuller) (c) defeat Angus O'Toole & Mr. Friday Night MPW Overdrive - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 18 | 29.12.2012 | |
Elimination: Team ELI (Drake Evans, Eli Thomas, Jeff Meekins, Kip Paige & Sean Reznikk) defeat Team Magnum (Angus O'Toole, Blair Andre Dillon, Joey Diamante, Mr. Friday Night & Shawn Blaze) MPW Wreck The Halls - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 19 | 17.11.2012 | |
Angus O'Toole defeats Drake Evans MPW Zero Tolerance - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 20 | 17.11.2012 | |
Eli Thomas & Jeff Meekins defeat Angus O'Toole & Blair Andre Dillon MPW Zero Tolerance - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 21 | 20.10.2012 | |
Eli Thomas defeats Angus O'Toole MPW Brawl-O-Ween - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 22 | 22.09.2012 | |
Jeff Meekins defeats Angus O'Toole MPW Fallout - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 23 | 11.08.2012 | |
25 Man Rumble By The Lake: The Bouncer defeats El Destroyer Canadienese (Scott Prodigy) and Angus O'Toole and Bill Rose and Blair Andre Dillon and Eli Thomas and Flea and Hector Havoc and Izeah Bonds and Jeff Meekins and Joey Vincent Martini and Johnny Mercury and Moondog Scrap and Rock Lobster and Ronin and Ronnie Deez and Ryan Burke and Sammy Marloman and Scott Prodigy and Senor Sanchez and Shawn Blaze and Southside Swagger and Super Nerd and The Moondog MPW Boiling Point! - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 24 | 11.08.2012 | |
MDW Tri-State Title Three Way Elimination: Thomas Adams defeats Brandon X (c) and Angus O'Toole - TITLE CHANGE !!! MPW Boiling Point! - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 25 | 14.07.2012 | |
MPW Tri-State Title #1 Contendership Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Angus O'Toole vs. Thomas Adams [1:1] - Double KO MPW 3-Demption - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 26 | 09.06.2012 | |
Chase 4 The Case Final Four Way: Lamont Williams defeats Angus O'Toole and Jeff Meekins and Seth Allen MPW Double Jeopardy - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 27 | 12.05.2012 | |
Chase 4 The Case First Round: Angus O'Toole defeats Brandon X by DQ MPW Collision Course - Event @ GO Ministries in Ashtabula, Ohio, USA |
| 28 | 20.04.2012 | |
MPW Heavyweight Title: Scott Prodigy (c) defeats Angus O'Toole MPW Resurgence - Event @ Jewell's Dance Hall in Austinburg, Ohio, USA |
