| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 09.11.1964 |  |
Luis Martinez defeats Tommy O'Toole Arizona Athletic Association - Event @ Phoenix, Arizona, USA |
| 2 | 29.09.1964 | |
Fidel Grimo & Tito Kopa defeat Indian Joe & Tommy O'Toole Arizona Athletic Association - Event @ Gardens in Tucson, Arizona, USA |
| 3 | 17.09.1964 | |
Al Kashey defeats Tommy O'Toole Big Bear Promotions - Event @ Tucson Sports Center in Tucson, Arizona, USA |
| 4 | 28.08.1964 |  |
Chris Averoff defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ State Fairgrounds in Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 5 | 24.08.1964 | |
Nick Kozak defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Park Center in Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 6 | 22.08.1964 | |
Jim Grabmire defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Memorial Auditorium in Spartanburg, South Carolina, USA |
| 7 | 18.08.1964 | |
Prince Omar defeats Tommy O'Toole by DQ JCP - Event @ Columbia, South Carolina, USA |
| 8 | 14.08.1964 | |
Jesse James defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ State Fairgrounds in Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 9 | 11.08.1964 | |
Doug Gilbert defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Dorton Arena in Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 10 | 07.08.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Jack Allen JCP - Event @ Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 11 | 04.08.1964 | |
Chief Big Heart & Ron Etchison defeat Doc Gallagher & Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 12 | 01.08.1964 | |
Mike Clancy defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Lexington, North Carolina, USA |
| 13 | 21.07.1964 | |
Tim Woods defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 14 | 18.07.1964 | |
Doug Gilbert defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Spartanburg, South Carolina, USA |
| 15 | 13.07.1964 | |
Tim Woods defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Park Center in Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 16 | 10.07.1964 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Alex Medina & Gino Brando defeat Tinker Todd & Tommy O'Toole [2:1] JCP - Event @ State Fairgrounds in Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 17 | 07.07.1964 | |
Chief Big Heart defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Dorton Arena in Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 18 | 04.07.1964 | |
Mike Clancy defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Spartanburg, South Carolina, USA |
| 19 | 30.06.1964 | |
Mike Clancy defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Dorton Arena in Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 20 | 26.06.1964 | |
John Heath defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ State Fairgrounds in Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 21 | 23.06.1964 | |
Alex Medina vs. Tommy O'Toole - Draw JCP - Event @ Memorial Auditorium in Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 22 | 15.06.1964 | |
Chief Big Heart defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Park Center in Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 23 | 12.06.1964 | |
Tim Woods defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 24 | 09.06.1964 | |
Ron Etchison defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 25 | 23.05.1964 | |
Alex Medina vs. Tommy O'Toole - Draw JCP - Event @ Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 26 | 22.05.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Bob Boyer JCP - Event @ Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 27 | 19.05.1964 | |
Gino Brando defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Columbia, South Carolina, USA |
| 28 | 18.05.1964 | |
Ron Etchison defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Greenville, South Carolina, USA |
| 29 | 12.05.1964 | |
Johnny Weaver & Ron Etchison defeat Frank Valois & Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 30 | 11.05.1964 | |
Bobby Red Cloud defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Park Center in Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 31 | 07.05.1964 | |
George Becker defeats Tommy O'Toole (7:00) JCP - Event @ Greensboro Coliseum in Greensboro, North Carolina, USA |
| 32 | 28.04.1964 | |
Jack Lanza defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 33 | 27.04.1964 | |
Johnny Weaver defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 34 | 18.04.1964 | |
Haystacks Calhoun defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Lexington, North Carolina, USA |
| 35 | 14.04.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Emile Dupree JCP - Event @ Columbia, South Carolina, USA |
| 36 | 06.04.1964 | |
Ron Etchison defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 37 | 31.03.1964 | |
Jack Allen defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Columbia, South Carolina, USA |
| 38 | 24.03.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Jack Kelly JCP - Event @ Columbia, South Carolina, USA |
| 39 | 19.03.1964 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Jack Allen & Jack Lanza defeat Frank Valois & Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Greensboro Coliseum in Greensboro, North Carolina, USA |
| 40 | 17.03.1964 | |
Angelo Martinelli defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Dorton Arena in Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 41 | 16.03.1964 | |
Bob Boyer & Emile Dupree defeat Frank Valois & Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Park Center in Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 42 | 13.03.1964 | |
George Becker defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 43 | 10.03.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Bobby Hart JCP - Event @ Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 44 | 07.03.1964 | |
Jack Lanza vs. Tommy O'Toole - Draw JCP - Event @ Lexington, North Carolina, USA |
| 45 | 06.03.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Sid Jones JCP - Event @ Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 46 | 02.03.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Bobby Hart JCP - Event @ Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 47 | 25.02.1964 | |
The Kentuckians (Luke Brown & Tiny Anderson) defeat George Harris & Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 48 | 24.02.1964 | |
Billy Cash vs. Tommy O'Toole - Draw JCP - Event @ Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 49 | 22.02.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Billy Cash JCP - Event @ Spartanburg, South Carolina, USA |
| 50 | 21.02.1964 | |
Johnny Weaver defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 51 | 17.02.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Sid Jones JCP - Event @ Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 52 | 15.02.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Alex Medina JCP - Event @ Spartanburg, South Carolina, USA |
| 53 | 14.02.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Billy Cash JCP - Event @ Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 54 | 13.02.1964 | |
Billy Cash defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Greensboro Coliseum in Greensboro, North Carolina, USA |
| 55 | 11.02.1964 | |
Emile Dupree defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 56 | 10.02.1964 | |
The Kentuckians (Luke Brown & Tiny Anderson) defeat George Harris & Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Greenville, South Carolina, USA |
| 57 | 08.02.1964 | |
Bobby Red Cloud & Jack Lanza defeat Joe Tomasso & Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Spartanburg, South Carolina, USA |
| 58 | 03.02.1964 | |
Emile Dupree defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 59 | 01.02.1964 | |
Emile Dupree defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Lexington, North Carolina, USA |
| 60 | 31.01.1964 | |
Emile Dupree defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 61 | 27.01.1964 | |
Jack Lanza vs. Tommy O'Toole - Draw JCP - Event @ Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 62 | 24.01.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Johnny Heidman JCP - Event @ Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 63 | 21.01.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Alex Medina JCP - Event @ Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 64 | 20.01.1964 | |
Bobby Red Cloud defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 65 | 18.01.1964 | |
The Kentuckians (Luke Brown & Tiny Anderson) defeat George Harris & Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Lexington, North Carolina, USA |
| 66 | 11.01.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Tom Bradley JCP - Event @ Lexington, North Carolina, USA |
| 67 | 10.01.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Tinker Todd JCP - Event @ Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 68 | 07.01.1964 | |
Swede Hanson defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Raleigh, North Carolina, USA |
| 69 | 03.01.1964 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Joe Tomasso JCP - Event @ Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 70 | 28.12.1963 | |
Jack Lanza defeats Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ YMCA in Lexington, North Carolina, USA |
| 71 | 14.12.1963 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Dr. Menendez JCP - Event @ YMCA in Lexington, North Carolina, USA |
| 72 | 13.12.1963 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Billy Parks JCP - Event @ State Fairgrounds in Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 73 | 07.12.1963 | |
Tinker Todd vs. Tommy O'Toole - Draw JCP - Event @ YMCA in Lexington, North Carolina, USA |
| 74 | 06.12.1963 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Tommy O'Toole defeats Dr. Menendez JCP - Event @ State Fairgrounds in Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 75 | 02.12.1963 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Billy Parks JCP - Event @ Park Center in Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 76 | 25.11.1963 | |
Bobby Red Cloud & George Becker defeat George Harris & Tommy O'Toole JCP - Event @ Park Center in Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 77 | 14.11.1963 |  |
Yukon Eric defeats Tommy O'Toole (10:36) MLW - Event @ Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| 78 | 08.11.1963 | |
The Great Mephisto defeats Tommy O'Toole (8:02) NWA Upstate Wrestlethon - Event @ Buffalo Memorial Auditorium in Buffalo, New York, USA |
| 79 | 31.10.1963 | |
Billy Red Lyons defeats Tommy O'Toole (16:55) MLW - Event @ Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| 80 | 24.10.1963 | |
Jim Hady defeats Tommy O'Toole (15:33) MLW - Event @ Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| 81 | 18.10.1963 | |
Don Reed defeats Tommy O'Toole (13:37) NWA Upstate - Event @ Buffalo Memorial Auditorium in Buffalo, New York, USA |
| 82 | 12.10.1963 | |
Johnny Barend defeats Tommy O'Toole NWA Upstate - Event @ Memorial Auditorium in Utica, New York, USA |
| 83 | 11.10.1963 | |
Johnny Valentine defeats Tommy O'Toole (6:15) NWA Upstate - Event @ Buffalo Memorial Auditorium in Buffalo, New York, USA |
| 84 | 28.09.1963 | |
Tony Marino defeats Tommy O'Toole NWA Upstate - Event @ Memorial Auditorium in Utica, New York, USA |
| 85 | 27.09.1963 | |
Tony Parisi defeats Tommy O'Toole (14:09) NWA Upstate - Event @ Buffalo Memorial Auditorium in Buffalo, New York, USA |
| 86 | 19.09.1963 | |
Dr. Jerry Graham defeats Tommy O'Toole (11:51) MLW - Event @ Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| 87 | 06.09.1963 | |
Bob Leipler defeats Tommy O'Toole (14:09) NWA Upstate - Event @ Buffalo Memorial Auditorium in Buffalo, New York, USA |
| 88 | 05.09.1963 | |
John Paul Henning defeats Tommy O'Toole (14:38) MLW - Event @ Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| 89 | 29.08.1963 | |
Dr. Jerry Graham defeats Tommy O'Toole (16:38) MLW - Event @ Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| 90 | 22.08.1963 | |
Killer Kowalski defeats Tommy O'Toole (9:32) MLW - Event @ Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| 91 | 17.07.1963 |  |
Bobo Brazil defeats Tommy O'Toole WWWF - Event @ McKeesport, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 92 | 13.06.1963 | |
Yukon Eric defeats Tommy O'Toole (8:56) MLW - Event @ Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| 93 | 03.06.1963 |  |
Duke Hoffman defeats Tommy O'Toole (15:53) Spectator Sports - Event @ Civic Arena in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 94 | 30.05.1963 | |
WWWF World Heavyweight Title: Bruno Sammartino (c) defeats Tommy O'Toole WWWF - Event @ Washington, District Of Columbia, USA |
| 95 | 28.05.1963 | |
Joe Esposito defeats Tommy O'Toole WWWF TV Taping - Event @ Bridgeport Arena in Bridgeport, Connecticut, USA |
| 96 | 21.05.1963 | |
Arnold Skaaland defeats Tommy O'Toole WWWF - Event @ Bridgeport Arena in Bridgeport, Connecticut, USA |
| 97 | 18.05.1963 | |
Argentina Apollo defeats Tommy O'Toole WWWF - Event @ Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 98 | 15.05.1963 | |
Al Samson vs. Tommy O'Toole - Time Limit Draw (20:00) WWWF - Event @ Weissglass Stadium in New York City, New York, USA |
| 99 | 04.05.1963 | |
Argentina Apollo defeats Tommy O'Toole WWWF - Event @ Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 100 | 30.04.1963 | |
Ron Reed defeats Tommy O'Toole Promotions Eddie Quinn - Event @ Coliseum in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada |
