| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 09.09.2000 - xx.xx.xxxx | ASWA Heavyweight Champion (as Mr. Insanity) | ? | Matches |
| 03.12.2016 - 10.02.2018 | ASWA Heavyweight Champion (3x) (as Toby Cline) | 434 days | Matches |
| 05.12.2015 - 08.10.2016 | ASWA Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Toby Cline) | 308 days | Matches |
| 12.05.2007 - 08.09.2007 | CZW Iron Man Champion | 119 days | Matches |
| 17.06.2006 - 30.09.2006 | IWA Mid-South Heavyweight Champion | 105 days | Matches |
| 09.07.2005 - 10.09.2005 | CZW Tag Team Champion (with Necro Butcher as The Tough Crazy Bastards) | 63 days | Matches |
| xx.06.2003 - xx.03.2005 | Mid-Ohio Heavyweight Champion | ? | Matches |
| 24.03.2002 - xx.xx.2002 | IWF Tag Team Champion (as Mr. Insanity; with Deranged) | ? | Matches |
| 22.06.2002 - 21.09.2002 | IWR Heavyweight Champion (as Mr. Insanity) | 91 days | Matches |
| 07.07.2002 - 07.07.2002 | XICW Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Mr. Insanity) | <1 day | Matches |
| xx.xx.2002 - 23.06.2002 | CAPW Heavyweight Champion (as Mr. Insanity) | ? | Matches |
| 03.06.2001 - 14.10.2001 | XICW Heavyweight Champion (as Mr. Insanity) | 133 days | Matches |
| 06.05.2001 - 06.05.2001 | XICW Xtreme Champion (as Mr. Insanity) | <1 day | Matches |
| 04.03.2001 - 06.05.2001 | XICW Tag Team Champion (as Mr. Insanity; with Brain Damage) | 63 days | Matches |
| 14.11.2000 - 18.02.2001 | FNW Heavyweight Champion (as Mr. Insanity) | 96 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| ASWA Heavyweight Championship (3x) | 742 (+ ?) days |
| CAPW Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| CZW New Horror Championship | 119 days |
| CZW Tag Team Championship | 63 days |
| FNW Heavyweight Championship | 96 days |
| IWA World Championship | 105 days |
| IWF Tag Team Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| IWR Heavyweight Championship | 91 days |
| Mid-Ohio Heavyweight Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| XICW Heavyweight Championship (2x) | 133 days |
| XICW Tag Team Championship | 63 days |
| XICW Xtreme Intense Championship | <1 day |
