| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 16.07.2021 - 31.07.2021 | ICW Dippin Donuts 24/7 Champion | 15 days | Matches |
| 29.06.2019 - 21.09.2019 | ICW Heavyweight Champion | 84 days | Matches |
| 10.09.2016 - 08.07.2017 | GSW Adrenaline Champion | 301 days | Matches |
| 19.11.2016 - 20.05.2017 | Dynasty Tag Team Champion (with Kevin Graham) | 182 days | Matches |
| 05.03.2016 - 10.09.2016 | NECW Tag Team Champion (with Jack Maverick as The Regulators) | 189 days | Matches |
| 13.08.2016 - 13.08.2016 | GSW Heavyweight Champion (2x) | <1 day | Matches |
| 14.06.2014 - 11.04.2015 | GSW Heavyweight Champion (as Punisher VanSlyke) | 301 days | Matches |
| 02.11.2013 - 31.05.2014 | WXW Elite Tag Team Champion (as Punisher VanSlyke; with Kevin Graham as First Class) | 210 days | Matches |
| 23.11.2013 - 19.04.2014 | 2CW Tag Team Champion (3x) (as Punisher VanSlyke; with Kevin Graham) | 147 days | Matches |
| 15.02.2013 - 24.06.2013 | 2CW Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Mike Van Slyke; with Kevin Graham as First Class) | 129 days | Matches |
| 11.02.2012 - 26.04.2012 | UW Internet Champion (as Punisher Van Slyke) | 75 days | Matches |
| 21.01.2012 - 14.04.2012 | 2CW Tag Team Champion (as Mike Van Slyke; with Kevin Graham as First Class) | 84 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| 2CW Tag Team Championship (3x) | 360 days |
| Dynasty Tag Team Championship | 182 days |
| GSW Adrenaline Championship | 301 days |
| GSW Heavyweight Championship (2x) | 301 days |
| ICW Dippin Donuts 24/7 Championship | 15 days |
| ICW Heavyweight Championship | 84 days |
| NECW Tag Team Championship | 189 days |
| UW Internet Championship | 75 days |
| WXW Elite Tag Team Championship | 210 days |
