[7.0] "Good triple threat... these 3 women had a better one after this one.I thought it was solid and didn't get into 2nd gear. also, the crowd didn't seem crazy into like that which hurts my score.I really liked the finish and that it is all I have to say about this match."
[7.0] "Good match between Charlotte, Becky and Carmella right here even though I have to admit I preferred their SmackDown match a few months later to determine Asuka's challenger, nevertheless this title match here is pretty cool and is most definitely one of the best encounters on this average SummerSlam PPV. Beyond the significance of this one as well as its legendary post-match angle with Becky finally turning on Charlotte, the match itself was very solid as the three connected well together and I didn't really notice any mistakes anywhere. It wasn't anything amazing but it was well paced, it was pretty cool to watch and I thought Carmella didn't look out of place at all next to the two top stars that Becky and Charlotte are. I really liked the ending which was super visual and then led to Becky being unleashed after the match, the rest is history of course."
[7.0] "War ein gutes Triple Threat Match wo Carmella die Schwächste war. Ist so denn Becky und Charlotte sind eine andere Liga. Am Schluss gewann wieder Charlotte. Becky hier als Heel tat ihr auch gut."
[7.0] "There are only a couple of reviews from beyond the week of the match, but little did people know what this would end up triggering. While at the time it was WWE misreading the mood and both putting the title on Flair and needlessly turning Lynch heel, it ended up being the moment that led to Becky Lynch becoming the biggest star in the industry, based mainly on the decisions that followed, and the fans not going along with the plan. At the time, it seemed senseless. Decent enough match though."
[5.0] "There are so many mistakes in this match. The match in itself was okay but so many times you had a wrestler that wasn't where it should. Carmella was actually good in it and the other two not so much. (**3/4)"
[7.0] "This match far exceeded my expectations in a good way. I think it was a fun match that made all 3 women look deserving of the title. However, there were some VERY questionable decisions made such as not having Becky win when the entire Barclay Center was chanting her name as well as turning Becky, a natural baby face, heel instead of Charlotte who has proven to be a fantastic heel in the past. The decision to turn Becky heel/Charlotte face backfired almost instantly and it really took away from the match. ***1/2"
[8.0] "Erinnerte in vielerlei Hinsicht an das Mania-Triple-Threat von Lynch, Flair und Banks. Carmella machte hier eine recht würdige Figur als Champion, aber geriet doch eher in eine Nebenrolle in der sich anbahnenden Fehde von Lynch und Flair. Entsprechend war das Match sehenswert, aber gerade Post-Match Szenen waren super. Lynch wirkt sehr glaubwürdig in ihrer frustrierten Heel-Rolle. Ich hoffe, sie kann in dieser Hinsicht ihren Charakter weiter ausbauen."
[6.0] "Solide Auseinandersetzung mit schönem Matchfluss und einer guten Schlussphase. Titelwechsel geht auch absolut klar, da ich den Titel nun wirklich nicht mehr länger an Carmella sehen wollte. *** von mir."
[9.0] "Great match, probably my favourite women's match of the year so far, if not my favourite then in the top 3. Ends an average title reign from Carmella, gives Flair another run as champ and sets up a feud between her and Lynch. Loved it"
[3.0] "One of the worst women's match that I have seen in the past months, according to the fighting stuff: the three most important spots are botched: Becky's double missile dropkick, Charlotte's corscrew moonsaultu and Carmella's sucide dive. The match gives me a sense of clumsiness, in fact the timing doesn't seem perfect. The rhythm of the match not too slow and the pretty story telled save the match from the oblivion, ** 1/2"
[5.0] "This was actual decent for the most part. Nothing was terrible and they all covered for each other well. That moonsault attempt was horrific though. **¾"
[7.0] "This match is basically like Becky Lynch vs. Charlotte vs. Sasha Banks for the Women's Title at WrestleMania 32. Except, replace Sasha Banks with Carmella. That does sound like quite a bit of a downgrade compared to the aforementioned match, but Charlotte and Becky were able to get somewhat of a clinic with Carmella in a big match scenario. If there were a 3rd really capable wrestler in this match though, this could have been another classic, but it's still just a good match."
[4.0] "Rough, awkward & sloppy for the first half or so + the flow wasn't there, but they got a solid thing going after a while, and the match turned out to be OK, overall. Super forgettable stuff though - just very paint by the numbers triple threat. The post-match angle with Becky turning on Charlotte was definitely the highlight. **"
[8.0] "Shocked this didn't have a rating here yet! Great match for all three of them and the finish was literally perfect. The writing of this whole Charlotte/Becky storyline so far has just been perfect. Charlotte is just entirely oblivious to Becky. And they knew that the fans would lose their mind with the finish playing out like that. It was perfect."
[8.0] "I'm just focusing on the match quality itself, not the eventual winner and post-match shenanigans. The match was really, really good. It was by far Carmella's best match, and she more than held her own in there against two far superior wrestlers. Charlotte's twisting moonsault is a thing of beauty. I didn't like the outcome and really hated the baffling decision to turn Becky heel afterwards, but the match was really good nonetheless."
