[7.0] "It's a pretty good match, but I did find it a bit annoying how Undertaker works on Cena's arm for several minutes and it doesn't really play into the finish. Cena was still a rookie at that time, but his selling on that is pretty spotty compared to Undertaker who sold his rib injury really well when he messed them up on a super plex. Still, this was a good old fashioned hard hitting match with Cena looking more and more like a future main event star. A-Train interfering in the match was logical after the pre-match comments."
[7.0] "A bit sloppy at points but still good. Undertaker absolutely brutalizes Cena's arm so badly in this match that Taz thinks he might tap out while not being in a hold. Cena logically got back in this by using a chain, and would also win by cheating.***1/2"
[8.0] "Ein feiner Schatz den ich jetzt auch gesehen habe (***1/2). Diese erste wirkliche Fehde vom Big Evil vs John wird ja von der WWE total verdrängt weil vieles von seiner Biker Zeit ja einfach nicht wieder aufgegriffen werden sollte. Das hier war noch besser als bei Vengeance 2003."
[8.0] "Really great match, what a beating by Undertaker roughing Cena up with great, great punches. Cena slipping through with the victory along with A-train's interference worked too"
[9.0] "Honestly this is a great match between Undertaker and a young Cena, maybe the feud that really turned people on to his potential. I remember clear as day Taz wondering if Cena would have to tap out without Taker even applying a submission because his arm was getting busted up so brutally. Top notch stuff."