[5.0] "The Undertaker is a great presence in the ring and the crowd was eating everything he does up so it's not horrible, but it is fairly underwhelming because even though its not necessarily a squash match, there was never a doubt who would win and that was a bad spot for Booker T in my opinion. The whole thing and pay off with the voodoo magic was bad and the match feels like it goes too long as it's not all that entertaining. Fair effort but it's just a bit meh overall."
[7.0] "The early presentation of Undertaker locking away his Harleys and bringing back the deadman gimmick is quite strange but I dug this feud in a campy way. It felt like a return to 1994 antics which is no insult from me. 'Taker played the hits in the way he's so good at doing, Booker was good at selling the fear while not getting totally jabroni'd."
[4.0] "For this being one of Undertakers return matches I'm shocked that he didnt get in more offense. The Booker T voodoo stuff was weird/bad and not sure how that helped Booker. At least the crowd ate up the Undertaker spots at the end, because outside of that this really wasnt too interesting, but the work was competent.**1/4"
[4.0] "This is the match with the classic ridiculous Michael Cole line of 'it is often debated whether or not the Undertaker is really alive or dead? '. The match itself is subpar - slow and plodding. The voodoo stuff from Booker is stupid, and other than that it is largely just the Undertaker reestablishing himself in the Deadman gimmick following WrestleMania. I suppose it achieved that, but it wasn't a very interesting way of going about it."
[7.0] "This was good but could have been a lot better, I don't think they treated Booker too well here as they were falling over themselves to portray Taker as unstoppable. Booker didn't really need the weird voodoo powder gimmick for sure, just let him be great."
[4.0] "Fine match that was done to show that Undertaker was back. The Undertaker win was predictable and it wasn't a big-time squash. Undertaker did sell for a few minutes. Cole tried to put over Booker's performance, but really, nobody thought the guy would win. The crowd was into all the usual Undertaker spots, which wasn't surprising at all. **."
