[5.0] "This was a match designed for Michael Cole to scream over, not a serious contest. I acknowledge that the performers worked hard but it also felt very passionless, an attempt at "big moments" to salvage a miserable storyline no one liked. Very sad to know this bunch of nothing was the last of Undertaker."
[7.0] "Last taker match in front of fans and he looked good. Smart move by WWE to have taker be in a tag team to protect him a bit. Finish was great with Elias interference, also I loved the part where mcintyre lines up for the claymore then boom spear. Takers sit up after the trash can bump was good too"
[7.0] "Pretty good, taker looked as good as hes ever gonna look, and he moved around very well, loved the interactions with drew and roman held up his end of the match too"
[8.0] "I am in shock how good Taker looks in this match, this man is simply amazing. Had me on edge a couple of times, even though this is almost every match with Taker in it ever: Shane does his trash can signature, and high risk action through the announcers' table, and Taker gets up after all of that, chokeslam, tombstone, match ends; at the same time, it's not a bother for me at all. Drew vs Deadman it's a absolute dream match, and I'm afraid this is the closest we can get to that dream, also they know it's a dream match-up so Taker and Drew have some cock-mesuring contest for a sec, love it. Elias' intervention was fine, and it added to the Takers' comeback later."
[8.0] "No holds barred tag match, it not being a tornado tag is just awful and they end up ignoring all tag team rules towards the end anyways. Everyone involved in this played their role well, even Elias's interference. Taker coming in with brief tags is so much better than him trying to work long matches at this stage in his career. The ending of Undertaker doing the sit up, and Reigns helping him to clear the ring for the win was great.****"
[7.0] "Annoying traditional tag rules in a NO HOLDS BARRED stipulation match aside, this was a surprisingly very good and enjoyable opener that the crowd was very much into. It worked well to hide the limitations of UT and Shane, and this was the best Taker has looked in years. Drew coming out of this looking great also, with an awesome shot of him stalking UT from behind being the highlight. [***1/2]"
[8.0] "Pretty excellent opening match between these four great performers and it's something that won't surprise anyone except those who criticized this match in advance when it was announced when Taker returned on an episode of Monday Night Raw, since Taker had decided to do this match to make us forget his terrible main event against Goldberg I don't think we should have judged that decision. The most important and cool thing for the fans is that this match delivered on top of having a real meaning for one of the four wrestlers, beyond the emotional aspect it was a fantastic tag match that only WWE has the secret to because they book it so well when they want to, unfortunately it doesn't happen often. Here it was your typical stipulation tag bout that we are used to seeing in this company but with some star-power and an epic side that was needed, the crowd was adorable with Taker by singing 'you still got it' from the beginning. Really nice brawl with good spots, a crowd on absolute fire and excellent booking, this match ruled."
[9.0] "This match was outstanding from start to finish. The Undertaker turned back the clocks for one night and both dished out tremendous offense and took some serious damage. We got the typical Shane McMahon moments, but they work well against the right opponents. As for Drew McIntyre and Roman Reigns, it is no coincidence that they were on top soon thereafter. Both were strong in this one, including the incredible visual of McIntyre rising up behind Taker. This all added up to a match that was all about the experience. Taker turning in one more memorable in-ring performance with an absolutely electric crowd watching him do so. One of my personal favorite matches. 4.5 stars, 9 out of 10."
[10.0] "very fun match.when you saw the undertaker last ride you will find out how this match was important for the undertaker.this match is so important to me as well.undertaker was so good at this match and i glade he was happy about this.crowd love it.taker love it and damn why we shouldn't love that?"
[5.0] "A bad match with overbooking for the sake of promoting Roman Reigns in a terrible fudge match with Shane McMahon. There wasn't anything outstanding in the match. Mostly standard holds and dominance."
[5.0] "It was not very good but I liked seeing Undertaker return and look like a human being again after some real disastrous encounters over the previous year."
[7.0] "I didn't expect anything special from the match. Old Undertaker and McMahon would seem to have what they can offer us. But the match turned out to be really good. A couple of dangerous spots from Shane and a very dynamic match in general. I put 4. 25 *."
[5.0] "Ich wundere mich wirklich über die vielen positiven Bewertungen hier. Das Match hat nicht wirklich viel, was mich irgendwie positiv beeindruckt, vor allem im Hinblick darauf, dass es ein No Holds Barred Match ist. Über weite Teil ist das Match ein normales Tag Match, bis Elias "endlich" eingreift und somit die Stipulation das erste Mal wirklich zum Tragen kommt. Ansonsten auch nur ein typisches Match der Beteiligten. Reigns zeigt seine 5 Moves, Taker zeigt seine Signatures, Shane muss wieder seine Sprünge zeigen, alles schon viel zu oft genau so gesehen. Erst nach Eingriff Elias' kommen doch noch ein paar gute Spots, aber mehr ist da auch nicht. Die komplette Phase ab dort ist nur noch auf ein paar Spots ausgelegt und Undertaker wird vermöbelt. Schön, dass er wieder in besserer Form zu sein scheint, aber das erwarte ich einfach auch in einem Match und ist nichts besonderes. Insgesamt also einfach nur ein paar Spots, die altbekannten Moves und viel nichts dazwischen (**1/4)"
[6.0] "Ganz netter Opener, der mich auch positiv überrascht. Der Taker ist klar in besserer Form als zuletzt, was dem Match natürlich ebenfalls hilft. Elias brauche ich da eigentlich nicht unbedingt mit drin, aber was solls viel verkehrt macht er ja nicht. Der Taker muss dann die klassischen Spots von Shane einstecken - letzterer kassiert aber den entscheiden Tombestone, welcher Reigns und den Taker zum Sieg führt. Das ist alles völlig im Rahmen."
[10.0] "This match was amazing, seriously. I did not expect it to be that damn good. All four men (and Elias) delivered a great performance, but I'm most impressed with Undertaker, who was in incredible shape compared to 2015-2018. After a horrendous botch fest with Goldberg at Super ShowDown, this was a great way for Undertaker to prove that he can still put on good matches when booked correctly."
[9.0] "Ich fand das war ein großartiges Spaß auch wenn Elias auftauchte und für ein No Holds Barred Match es nicht so hart war wie ich es kenne aber das ist halt die WWE und im Rahmen der Möglichkeiten wurde ich super unterhalten (****)."
[8.0] "This was just a blast. Super fun seeing Taker on a PPV outside of Mania mixing it up with someone he hasn't faced before in McIntyre. And he looked better than he has in a good while. Everyone else worked really hard to make this work too. Fun chaotic tag match."
[7.0] "An ungewohnter Position auf der Card bekommt man einen prominent besetzten Einheizer mit zwar erwartbarem, aber auch vorzeigbarem Ablauf. Der Brawl verläuft lange ausgeglichen und die Moves wirken nicht überhitzt oder unangemessen, so dass man allmählich die Crowd hinter sich arbeitet, was für einen Opener ja die Hauptaufgabe darstellt. Am Ende gibt es die üblich deftigen Shane-Impacts, die in letzter Konsequenz vom Taker aber nur halbherzig verkauft werden, so dass die Faces mit dem offensichtlichen Erfolg die Show starten. Das ist zwar nicht der Originalität letzter Schluß, aber es wirkt seriös und angemessen."
[7.0] "I loved this match. All Wrestlers have fought well, there are the usual spots of shane McMahon and the beautiful comeback of the Undertaker. Elias assault was an a good idea. Rating ***3/4"
[6.0] "Das Match war eine positive Überraschung für mich. Der Undertaker zeigt sich in deutlich besserer Form als zuletzt und kann all seine Trademarks gut und sauber ausführen. Roman Reigns und Drew McIntyre können ihre Kraft zeigen. Shane McMahon zeigt zwar mal wieder seine furchtbaren Punches, aber dafür passen seine klassischen Shane Spots zumindest zu dem Extreme Rules Motto und er kassiert mehr, als er es schon getan hat. Zudem gefällt mir auch das Ende mit dem Tombstone, was dann wirklich passend ist. Allerdings ist mir die Bewertung von Meltzer zu hoch. Mich stört ein bisschen das Overbooking mit Elias und zum anderen muss man sagen, dass das Ganze zwar anständig geworked war und die Zuschauer drin waren, aber keine große Story erzählt wurde. Es hatte durchaus Emotion und war insgesamt stimmig aber es war weder handwerklich übermäßig spektakulär noch von der Story. Es war einfach "nur" anständig und überdurchschnittlich gut und daher 6 Punkte."
[5.0] "Emotionless match. It looks like the same tag team match. The usual spots of Shane McMahon. The match didn't observe the stipulation, a NO-DQ match would be the same. Elias' assault was a little bit forced. The usual comeback of The Undertaker, but he did well during the match. Rating * * *"
[7.0] "This was fun. Taker looked pretty damn good & so did all the others involved. The Elias interference added a lot to the thing too, as I feel like that's when it kicked into another gear."
[6.0] "Dieses Match hat wahnsinnig überrascht, Taker wirkte hier noch echt fit und obwohl es jetzt kein Super Match war, war es doch sehr ordentlich, was ich nicht habe kommen sehen. ***1/4"
[8.0] "Really fun stuff and a hot opener. Working around the Undertaker's limitations ended up with him looking better than he has in awhile. The Shane stuff might be overplayed but the arena was definitely ready to see him get destroyed and it made for a fun match."
[7.0] "Bestes Taker Match seit Jahren [Lesnar, HIAC 2015? ]. Spielt seine Best Hits, während die anderen das Tempo halten. Ist schon over bookt, aber die Schlussphase macht ordentlich Laune (***½). + der Undertaker sieht in aktueller Verfassung sogar noch mehr wie ein Deadman aus. Auch wenn das Finish möglicherweise ebenfalls als Retirement dient, kann ich mir vorstellen, dass er mit solchen Best Hits Matches noch etwas gehen kann."
