[4.0] "Not one of the best Raw episodes to be honest but I actually thought the Triple H vs. Eugene match was quite well worked, especially those opening exchanges where Triple H was getting out wrestled. It was an okay match that I thought did fine in advancing the Benoit/HHH main event feud. The problem with this Raw for me was that so much of the focus not only wasn't on the matches, but in general was focused on things that had nothing to do with wrestling whatsoever. The whole diva search thing was ridiculous and I already feel like I have a few weeks of pain to look forward to watching that! The Kane storyline goes way too far here as well where Lita is pregnant and it might be Kane's baby, but it was her fault even though she was raped! What kind of writing is that? It's one of the worst storylines I have ever seen in the WWE and I'm not exaggerating when I say I think it's as bad as the Katie Vick storyline! Not everything here is bad. There's a good Evolution tag team match as usual, the Trish v Victoria match was decent if not a little short, Regal has some good babyface fire to him before he gets destroyed by Kane and the Rock starting the show off with a promo in his home town is always going to be fun to watch! This show is a mixed bag overall, but the worst storyline is sticking out really badly at this point."

[3.0] "Wish the whole show would've just been The Rock cutting promos, and that one tag match since that was solid because everything outside of that wasn't good. The Lita/Kane stuff gets worse every week, there's a ton of plugging on the diva search(Who cares about that? ) Eugene is supposedly a comedy character, who can also go damn near 17 minutes with a main eventer like Triple H, that's comical."

[3.0] "This was a bad and oddly paced show, with The Rock being one of the few highlights, as this was the beginning of Eugene's main event push, which didn't work as comedy characters shouldn't be in the main event."

[4.0] "Schlechte Ausgabe von RAW. Das Anfangssegment war exzellent. The Rock besucht wie in letzter Zeit einmal im Monat die RAW Show und witzelt erstmal so rum bis Orton aufkreuzt doch auch mit ihm wird er verbal fertig. Bischoff wollte Rocky nicht mehr in der Arena haben und schmeißt ihn raus. Edge verpasst Orton den Spear was somit klar ist das Edge und Orton bei Vengeance ein Match haben werden. Die Divas waren schlecht. Trish verteidigt unspektakulär und bevor Victoria mehr Schaden kassiert wird sie von einer nicht näher erläuterten Person aus dem Ring gezogen. Es sah nach Richards als Frau verkleidet aus. Regal braucht nicht mehr der Manager von Eugene sein und ist nun wieder ein aktiver Wrestler. Ein Match mit Kane gab es nicht und er wurde fertig gemacht. Evolution vs Jericho und Edge war in Ordnung. Jericho musste bei der Hälfte verletzt aus dem Match rausgenommen werden. Für Edge alleine waren Orton und Batista zu viel. Matt Hardy war zunächst überglücklich das Lita schwanger ist und macht ihr einen Heiratsantrag doch Kane unterbricht und verkündet das Lita nicht ehrlich war und das das Kind nicht von Matt Hardy ist. Der Main-Event war nichts besonderes. Ein seltenes langes Match was mir nicht gefiel. Die erste Hälfte war eher freundschaftlich bis Triple H keine Lust mehr hatte und ernst machte. Er hätte den Sieg geholt aber Bischoff meinte er müsste Eugene zerstören. Benoit verpasst am Ende Eugene ausversehen einen Stuhlschlag und Benoit wird von Evolution überrumpelt."

[2.0] "This was very much not a good show. A surprise Rock appearance eats up a full half hour of the show and it's just a meandering promo connected to nothing, though at least it was fun watching Orton have exaggerated reactions to Rock's insults, which have not aged very well. This leaves room on the card for only three matches, only one of which is good. But don't worry, there's still time for countless "Diva Search" clips of Coach ogling barely interested women, and don't forget the "exciting" revelation that Lita is carrying Kane's evil baby. At least Smackdown has JBL to keep things entertaining."