[7.0] "Die Show ging sehr schnell vorbei und das im Guten. Klar die Matches waren alle zu kurz und dienten zum Aufbau / Weiterentwicklung von Fehden und Charakteren, aber als solche waren Sie nicht schlecht und man wusste klar was passiert. Der rote Faden der Folge mit Foley als neuen Commsioner, der unterhaltsam ist aber gegen Ende doch zu oft in erscheinung tritt, Shanes Match gegen The Rock und die abschließende Allianz von Benoit mit Shane, sorgen dafür, dass man das Gefühl hat tatsächlich Veränderung im Status Quo gesehen zu haben. Plus die schiere Starpower der Card."

[7.0] "Mick Foley is a great Commissioner. Shane is with Benoit now. First match was pretty good. Closing moment of the show was good too."

[7.0] "Mick Foley and Rock had a great segment, Foley in particular this episode was amazing. The matches here were fine and probably peaked with the opening match, which was only 4 minutes and ended really fast. Closing angle with Benoit aligning with Shane was really strong"

[5.0] "There was basically nothing of interest here outside of Shane starting his alliance with Benoit. A surprisingly boring episode this week."

[8.0] "Very strong episode, Mick Foley is a delight as commissioner and Shane McMahon does a great job holding up the McMahon-Hemsley promos this week were as other episodes around this period have suffered from too much HHH in that role. The show did feel upside down some how starting off really hot and trailing off a bit, but still a good watch."