[5.0] "A very jam-packed episode of SmackDown, the tag turmoil match was fun and the main event was fine for what it was. The Boss Man and Al Snow segment is funny in a bad, stupid way"

[8.0] "Outside of the tuxedo match and HHH/Gillberg this was another good episode, that featured the debut of the Dudleys, who started a feud with the Acolytes."

[8.0] "This was an entertaining show and one that was very easy to watch. Rock and Mankind's segment together is gold, that segment where Bossman tricks Al Snow into eating his own dog was also good. Jericho's shtick with Finkel is starting to grow on me. It's actually pretty funny. Main event had a hot crowd and was a good way to send the crowd home happy."

[6.0] "An entertaining lightweight show that's fun to watch in the moment but with very little that's going to stick with you after you're done with it. There was some seriously wacky stuff here with Jericho and a fantastically poor taste segment with Bossman tricking Al Snow into eating his dog."

[7.0] "Cool show even without big main feud. Opening (not really) segment is entertaining, Show/Taker relationships are interesting. I also was very surprised with the turmoil match and of course with 3D debut. Some trash stuff as here is one of the most legendary segments of all time? with Al Snow and Big Bossman. Main event is alright. Not the most important show but definitely an entertaining and fun one."