 # | Date | User | Rating | Comment |
| 1 | 18.11.2016 | jboyaquar | 4.0 | A Monroe's appearance and skillset evoke a poor-woman's N Savoy but she certainly had the crowd. W/ Luscious Latasha on the card D Nicole needs to fine a better way to distinguish herself. Mercedes re-established herself in an in-ring interview. I like the concept and entrance music of Thunderkitty's retro gimmick but the slow-burn, unathletic content of all her matches doesn't perk me up. Good pointed post-match mic work challenging longtime veteran M Hosaka for the next show. Short four-way to get these ladies on the card and to continue Latasha's streak of unlikely victories. I wished the statuesque K Klein and adorable Raquel from T Enough got more time; Shine is less in-ring and more cosmetic dependent than other women's feds so I'm not surprised that R went over. Better in-ring presence by A Gallows than the norm and her backslide bridge was impressive. 5 matches in and not one over 2 stars. Make it six as V Kraven used a ref bump to pick-up a victory over one of the most popular ladies in Shine. Make it seven as I'm ill to So Cal/An's long-standing schtick leading to the overlong heat segment. Not 8 though as despite Kay/Bale's lumbering, they had a fine match based around Kay's bullying (Bale ended up in the trash) and Bale using a Kay mistake to work over Kay's hand... almost to victory via an Octopus stretch. Finally, in the heated main, Su didn't lose any steam passing out to Ive's Kondo Clutch and then turned on her management post... but only 11 for a title match? ! |
| 2 | 24.07.2016 | Grissom | 6.0 | Die Card wirkt zunächst nicht wirklich einladend, zumindest was die Mid und Undercard angeht, aber ich war doch positiv überrascht von den Matches. Alles grundsolide auf einem akzeptablen Level und gut anschaubar ohne Ausfälle. SHINE hat es anscheinend auch endlich erkannt, dass die Anzahl der völlig übertriebenen und unsauberen Finishes nicht mehr tragbar in den Shows sind und man da einen Gang runtergefahren ist. Gut so. Wenn es so bleibt, dann ist SHINE wieder auf einem guten Weg. Das Highlight der Show war der Main Event. Endlich bekommt Su Yung ihren Titleshot. Leider ist es gegen Ivelisse , die sich den Titel erst bei SHINE 35 sichern konnte und somit der Ausgang relativ klar war. Das Match war trotzdem gut, auch dank der Backstory um Su Yung, die sich hier endgültig von Valkyrie trennen kann und den überfälligen Faceturn durchführt. |
