[8.0] "UPDATE: Opener (*** 1/2) hätte noch besser sein können, Whitmer vs. Page (** 1/2), Goto vs. Castle (***), Shelley vs. Daniels (** 1/4) sehr enttäuschend, Tanahashi & Elgin vs. Briscoes (*** 3/4), Okada vs. Moose (*** 1/4), NEVER 6 Man TT Title (**** 1/2) einfach nur göttliches Spotwrestling mit Story - besser geht nicht mehr, War Machine vs. ANE (*** 1/4), Promos zum ME sehr gut gelungen, ME (*** 3/4) beginnt leider relativ zäh - gegen Ende hin aber einfach awesome. Insgesamt 7, 78/10 - 'gut'."

[7.0] "This rating includes the dark match . This was a good show but really didn't have a big show feel . New Japan guys mostly went over . There where some botch type issues that marred some of the early matches . Having said that every match was good and three matches where very good . Worth watching : everything . My top match was Jay Lethal (w/Taeler Hendrix & Truth Martini) (c) vs. Adam Cole vs. Kyle O'Reilly ."

[6.0] "This show was disappointing but had enough key moments to save it from being bad. Roddy vs Ishii vs Fish. ***1/2. Good given its time. All were able to showcase their abilities. Page vs Whitmer. **1/2. An odd booking. A rushed feud, not much chemistry or build up, and a stupid finish. Castle vs Goto. ***1/4. Great seeing the all-around power of Castle and the vicious strength of Goto. Disappointing botched finish though. Shelley vs Daniels. **1/2. Very odd, without much chemistry or flow. It was obvious that the Motor City reunion was coming eventually, but it was still very welcomed. Elgin/Tanahashi vs The Briscoes. ***1/2. Quite fun. Two great teams with great chemistry. Moose vs Okada. ***1/4. An odd booking, but both got to show off their unique abilities. Chemistry wasn't always great though. The Elite vs ACH, Kushida, and Sydal. ****. A spotfest, but enjoyable all the way. Each wrestler showed they were great performers. War Machine vs ANX. **3/4. Slow at times and a dull crowd. Got better with the weapons/objects being introduced, and the teams got more comfortable with their moves, but things got sloppy near the very end. Lethal vs Cole vs O'Reilly ***1/2. Lacked some energy or chemistry at times, and slow at the start, but very good in the second half. An enjoyable event, but disappointing still. The booking was already a bit questionable, and the matches didn't all live up to their potential, but this wasn't at all bad and had enough entertaining moments."

[7.0] "Eine recht enttäuschende Show. Kein einziger Titelwechsel und kein kracher Match. Desweiteren gab es 2 starke Matches in Elite vs Sydal, Kushida und ACH (*** 3/4) und dem Main Event (*** 1/2*). Der rest der Card war einfach nur standartkost... Das ist aber zu wenig für eine große Jubiläumsshow. Trotzdem recht gutes Niveau."

[7.0] "Gute aber nicht aussergewöhnlich gute Show. Der Opener war unterhaltsam und o. k. , aber ehrlich gesagt nicht das was ich erwartet hatte. Vorallem hätte ich Fish mal den Titel gegönnt. Die folgenden drei Matches waren alle auf einem guten TV-Show Format und waren für die Under- und Midcard brauchbar. Richtig los ging der Event erst ab dem ersten Tag Team Match. Hier wurde man zum ersten Mal wirklich ins Match gezogen und hat mitgefiebert. Auch Okada vs Moose war ein schönes Match. Vorallem die Anspielungen auf die beeindruckenden Drop Kicks der beiden haben mir gefallen. Klares MotN war das Six Man Tag Team Match. Ein Spotfest vor dem Herren. Das war wirklich Nonstop Action und hat wenn man diese Art von Wrestling mag einfach nur unheimlich Spaß gemacht. Das Tag Team Titelmatch war anfangs ein Downer, hat sich gegen Ende aber doch noch einmal deutlich gesteigert und hatte mit dem Bump durch die Leiter und den Tisch noch zwei richtig starke Spots. Der Main Event war solide und konnte 15 Minuten gut unterhalten. Das Finish war unterhaltsam gebookt, auch wenn ich eigentlich nie das Gefühl hatte das Lethal verlieren könnte. Aber das ist bei ROH Championship Matches nicht so ungewöhnlich. Insgesamt eine wrestlerisch ansprechende Show, die aber am Anfang der Card die ein oder andere kleine Enttäuschung zu bieten hatte."

[8.0] "This was a good card. Worst match was Whitmer vs. Page and really it was okay. It was just the match the crowd was the least excited for. The TV Title match as good. I liked Goto vs. Castle. Shelley vs, Daniels was good. And I'm excited for The Motor City Machine Guns reunion. Tanahashi and Elgin vs. The Briscoes was a fun match. Okada gave Moose the best match he ever had. The six man tag team was amazingly fun to watch. The World Tag Team Title match was good but the placement wasn't good and the crowd died. The World Title match was good but time was running out and it was rushed."

[7.0] "Für mich kam es wieder nicht wie eine Anniversary Show vor. Es gibt ROH jetzt schon 14 Jahre und es wurde wieder nichts gefeiert, spart man wohl für den 15th Geburtstag da erwartet ich auch einige ROH Legenden der Vergangenheit zu Gast. Es war ein normaler ROH PPV mit einigen gute Matches und einen sehr starken NEVER Openweight Six Man Tag Team Title Match (****) das war für mich Match of the Night. Main Event war gut aber es machte nie richtig klick bei mir und es war nicht so stark wie auf dem Card (***1/4). Es passierte hier auch nichts besonderes außer das Kenny seinen Besen ein Headset gab Funny Moment of the PPV. Etwas enttäuschend von ROH 14th Anniversary gerade vom Opener (***), Alex Shelley vs. Christopher Daniels (**1/4) und dem Main Event hab ich viel mehr erwartet, 7 Punkte."

[9.0] "A great show, and I have no idea how people can think it was below-average. Almost every match on this card was *** or better, with the only exceptions being Whitmer/Page and Shelley/Daniels, and even then both those matches were inoffensive and forwarded angles (Page's face turn and progression as a singles talent, MCMG reforming). The crowd was generally good, with the exception of the Tag Title match, which fell a bit flat having to follow the fantastic NEVER Trios Title match (and it doesn't help that practically nobody cares about ANX), but some of the big spots started getting a reaction towards the end. The New Japan Talent were all over and on the top of their game, but it felt odd that they went over in every single match; it sort of made ROH look a little beneath them. I really think Castle should've gotten the win over Goto, at the very least. Still, I would say that Ishii/Strong/Fish, Castle/Goto, Briscoes/Elgin & Tanahashi, and Moose/Okada were very good, while the aforementioned Elite/ACH, Sydal, & KUSHIDA match and the main event were just great. The main event felt longer than it was in a good way, and I loved the story of the match and how it was important to the dynamic all the way to the finish. Also, ROH's new stage is a huge improvement and shows Sinclair is finally giving them serious funding. A very good show with a handful of booking flaws, but I'll throw a 9 at it because it deserves a better overall score."

[8.0] "Very good show, I really enjoyed the new titantron. Best match the 6 man tag. The ROH-NJPW relationship really helps ROH to build stronger and far better shows and this ppv is proof of that."

[5.0] "Ich vermisse die guten ROH Zeiten, wo es mehr gab als nur Spots im Ring, Submissions noch verkauft wurden und Leute wie War Machine, Page, Castle und Moose maximal im Darkmatch gewesen wären. Doch es ist 2016 und ROH Wrestling ist im Grunde nur noch Highspots, No-Selling von Bumps und vor allem Submissions. Schlecht nicht, jedoch übel langweilig. Main Event und Briscos vs. Elgin & Tanahashi fand ich ordentlich (***), der Rest war mir zu anstrengend bzw. zu lahm und uninteressant. ROH braucht jemanden, der den Ref beobachtet und entsprechend korrekt die Ringglocke bedienen kann - wer immer das jetzt macht suckt derbe in diesem Job. Die Kommentaren klangen bis auf Nigle alle, als hätten sie zwei Tage nicht geschlafen; sehr emotionslos. Die ruhige Crowd schieb ich mal auf die miese Soundanlage, da kam recht wenig rüber. Am besten fand ich, als King aus dem Finish von War Machine auskickt und NIEMAND dafür poppt. Außerdem frag ich mich, ob Castle je ein Match von Goto geschaut hat; möglicherweise hätte er dann den Finisher von Goto vernünftig nehmen können. Vielleicht wäre es besser gewesen, zwei, drei Matches zu streichen und anderen Matches mehr Zeit zu geben, sich vernünftig entwickeln zu können. ROH Einheitsbrei, der vor allem TNA und WWE Hassern sehr gut gefallen dürfte."

[4.0] "This wasn't ANYTHING special. You can write off Page/Whitmer, Goto/Castle (What a waste of Goto btw), Shelley/Daniels (a real disappointment), and the War Machine match. Ishii/Fish/Strong was fine, but being a triple threat nobody could go all out. I'm glad Ishii kept the title though. The same can be said about the main event, although that was a little better. Okada/Moose was decent but just that. Gotta give credit to Moose for improving at the rate he has and keeping up with Okada. Tana/Elgin vs. Briscoes was really fun, I give it 3. 5 stars. The best match and the only match I'd call great was the NEVER 6-man match. Everybody was so good there and Sydal is probably very sore right now. But in the end, we're left with a "supercard" where half the matches were crap/skippable, two decent matches, and two matches that were just "good", and only one great match. It was just a disappointing event."

[6.0] "I would call it an OK show. I expected a better show here. It wasn't bad, but I think it could have been better. The opener was a really good match for a time given (*** 1/4). BJ vs Page was not a good match (* 1/2). Goto vs Castle was also underwhelming (** 1/4). Shelley vs Daniels was ok, but the whole thing was built around MCMG reunion (** 3/4). Tana&Elgin vs Briscoes was really good (*** 1/4), and so was Okada vs Moose (*** 1/4). Omega and Bucks vs ACH, Sydal and KUSHIDA was an awesome match (**** 1/4). Match of the night. The no DQ match had a hard time following NEVER title match. An OK match (** 1/4). The main event was a very very good match, altough it was kinda underwhelming (*** 1/2). This was a solid show, but there was nothing great besides of the 6 man tag team match."

[8.0] "Die Card war mir etwas zu überfüllt und mir missfällt dass wirklich jeder NJPW Wrestler unbedingt gewinnen muss. gerade ein Goto kann doch mal verlieren. Tut er "zu Hause" doch oft genug. Opener, Castle/Goto, Tanahashi & Elgin vs. Briscoes waren alle solide (***1/4). Der Rest der Undercard ging in Ordnung auch wenn man vieles in die Weekly hätte ausgliedern können. MCMG Reunion war aber trotzdem cool. Spotfest der Elite war spaßig(****1/4), War Machine/ANX ***3/4 und Main Event ****1/2 ziehen die Show nochmal nach oben."

[6.0] "This was pretty solid but unspectacular show. By far the best match was the Six Man Tag. It was such a crazy match and I really enjoyed it. Main Event was pretty good even though I expected more. Tana/Elgin-Briscoes was the third best match of the show. The rest was average or below average."

[1.0] "An awful show. The opener was meh, but actually in my opinion, the 2nd best match of the night (**). Page/Whitmer, Castle/Goto & Daniels/Shelley were all awful (*), so were TanaElgin/Briscoes & Okada/Moose (*1/4), the best match of the night was the 6-man tag, which was VERY good (***3/4), the tag title match was awful (*), and the main event was bad (*1/2). This was such a bad show. The only match that I enjoyed was The Elite vs. ACH, KUSHIDA & Sydal."