[7.0] "Easily the best TNA show so far; we're actually entering a decent little stretch starting with this one (minus the X-Division Special.) A great best of three series done in one show takes place here between AJ Styles and Jerry Lynn. Brian Lawler is angry at his former friend Double J but we don't know why. James Storm and Chris Harris' interview is my favourite segment. I was really surprised how put together this show was."

[7.0] "This is easily the best show TNA has put on so far. We open with A.J. Styles and Jerry Lynn in a falls count anywhere match. This is far from their best outing, which means that it's just good. Next we get the soon to be named America's Most Wanted taking on the thrown together team of Ron Harris and Brian Lee. This might be the best Ron Harris match I've seen, since I didn't hate it. We get Sonny Siaki taking on Jimmy Yang in a 2-out-of-3 falls match next, and its better than you'd think based on their performances an the Elvises. Slash and Brian Lawlor show up next, to bring the mood down, but even that isn't as awful as I had feared. TNA go back to the well with the trio vs Low-Ki in a four-way gimmick, although it's less good this time. Monty Brown and Ron Killings is completely fine, and then we get Styles and Lynn two more times. First we gen a no-DQ match, which is the best of the series, followed by an iron man match which isn't. Overall, this show is definitely worth a watch."

[6.0] "Perhaps it's one of the best shows TNA did until this point. The best match is Lynn vs AJ, eventhough is not their best and the stipulation was weird. I really enjoyed the DQ match. Also Low Ki's defense was quite entertaining and had cool spots. The tag match between AMW and Brian Lee y Ron Harris was a good match until the finish, what a horrible end to a good match. The NWA title match wasn't very good. The same goes with Brian Lawler storyline. I recommend to watch only Lynn vs AJ, The X Division title match and the tag team one."

[3.0] "I dont get the positive reviews. Almost every match had a stupid stipulation that made it bad and the matches without stipulation were just bad"

[6.0] "For some reason, once you rate on one AJ/Lynn match, Cagematch applies your rating to them all. This was a pretty good episode of TNA with solid wrestling throughout. I am also the one person who enjoys Brian Lawlor as the ass kicking dude out for revenge. A nice lack of racism compared to previous episodes."

[4.0] "I thought this was a very sub-par episode outside the AJ/Jerry Lynn series of matches. The heavyweight bouts were mostly terrible and the x-division spotfests didn't do a lot for me. I also wasn't as enthused by the lack of non-wrestling segments, since even though they were largely awful they did serve a function in breaking up the show and helped make it more digestible."

[7.0] "This is the first show that I think is actually decent from early NWA-TNA. And yes, it's pretty much all due to the young X Division. But even the non-X Division stuff is passable."

[6.0] "The best part about this episode is the X division. The AJ/Lynn series, Siaki/Yang, Low-Ki's title defense show why the division has been a cornerstone of the company. The rest of the show is okay to good."

[4.0] "Not a very good show but nothing truly horrible, so it? s got a big advantage on some of these early shows. AJ and Lynn start well, though it? s not one of their best bouts as they are holding back for later. Tag match was bad, Brian Lee isn? t great and Ron Harris stinks, and the end of the match is confusing as hell. Yang/Siaki was on its way to being good but the finish is even worse, Siaki holds the ropes as the ref stares right at him and counts the pin. We chaotically segue into the next match with a bad Jeff Jarrett segment, and then the next match is also bad. Brian Lawler actually seems to be trying, god bless him, but I haven? t a clue what they? re doing with him. Jeff Jarrett again, then XD four way is the best match of the night, not very logical but certainly some awesome action. Monty/Killings isn? t very good, Brown is explosive but still growing, and Killings is a good talker but a lousy wrestler. Jeff Jarrett again after the match, jeez. The two AJ/Lynn matches try hard but are honestly pretty disappointing, everything seems very messy, nothing is paced well, the stipulations are all out of whack, and it? s hard to have any kind of good focus or structure. At least Low Ki challenged both guys to a ladder match next week, which should be great I hope. MORE Jarrett to end the show, but at least it was an angle that made me feel a bit interested for once."

[8.0] "Eine der deutlich besseren frühen TNA Shows, da man den ganzen Bullshit mal weggelassen hat und sich auf die reine In-Ring-Qualitäten konzentriert. Lynn und Styles tragen auf Grund ihrer marathonleistung natürlich die Show, aber auch der 4 Way war gut und auch das andere 2 out 3 Falls Match konnte sich sehen lassen."

[7.0] "Der Opener wie erwartet gleich mal stark, TT Match schwach, 2 out of n3 Falls ist zwar ganz gut aber ich hätte mehr erwartet, das Lawler Match wie immer nix, X-Division Championship auch in Ordnung aber war auch mehr drin, Killings vs Brown langweilt mich, die beiden folgenden Lynn vs Styles Matche sind beide sehr gut aber das ME war mir dann doch zu lang. Alles in Allemn ein ordentliches Match aber leider konnten mich nicht alle Matche so überzeugen wie ich es erwatet hätte."

[8.0] "Insgesamt, der X-Division sei dank, eine durchgehend unterhaltsame Show. Die drei Lynn vs. Styles-Matches mögen nicht zu den ganz großen Klassikern ihrer legendären Fehde zählen, sind aber dennoch allesamt gut. Siaki vs. Yang steht diesen Matches kaum nach und auch Lo-Kis zweite Titelverteidigung gegen ein komplettes Stable in Folge ist gelungen. Den Rest der Show kann man sich soweit auch noch ansehen, auch wenn das World Titelmatch mit zunehmender Dauer die Schwächen von Monty Brown aufzeigt. Lediglich der Cliffhanger um Jarrett und Bullet Bob Armstrong hat mich eher kalt gelassen."

[6.0] "Die Best of Three Serie war ganz nett gemacht, auch wenn es kein Match gabt, an das man sich acht Jahre später noch mal erinnern würde. Zumindest erinnere ich mich and die Serie und auch an die Frage, warum man in Gotten Namen das gleiche Gimmick bei einer Show zweimal braucht, den Siaki vs Yang ist ein 2 of 3 Falls Match, und noch nicht mal ein sonderlich gutes (**). Styles und Lynn kommen in der Folge auf ***, ***1/4 und nochmal ***. Ki gegen das komplette SAT war ganz ansehlich (**3/4), was man von Lawler vs Slash nicht sagen kann. Über Killings habe ich damals geschrieben, dass es besser für ihn währe, wenn er endlich mal die Leistung bringen würde, die man von ihm erwartete, sonst wäre der Zug bald für ihn abgefahren. Nicht, dass man mit Brown ein besseres Match als ** haben könnte."

[7.0] "Die Serie zwischen AJ Styles und Jerry Lynn brache in meinen Augen an diesem Abend 3 wirklich klasse Matches hervor, allerdings auch nichts, was man sagen könnte, muss man gesehen haben. Siaki vs. Jimmy Yang war auch ein starkes Technik Match mit schönen Aktionen. X Division Championship war auch wie man an den Teilnehmern schon erkennen kann ein starkes Match, aber wie gesagt, kein unvergessliches Match dabei. 7 Punkte"