[2.0] "At this stage of the game, the faction has had time to breathe. So far though, it has been a lot of flash and no substance. People coming to view this faction will be carrying a lot of baggage due to the untimely and unfortunate death of Bray Wyatt. Even detractors will say that he was a very creative man who inspired a lot of wrestling fans with his character work. This character work and the history of Wyatt's work in WWE form the catalyst of this faction's formation. Currently, this faction is a tribute act to the man. If Bray did not die, this would be terrible. It is still terrible. The booking of it flies in the face of what reality WWE hews to. It has room to grow but will require WWE to invest a whole lot to make it work. I can see it work as an eventual exorcism of the group's collective grief, but until then it is nonsensical hokum that worked in Lucha Underground (a show I love) but does not work here at all. As time progresses, this faction is increasingly insipid, directionless, and a dowsing rod for fans who have no concept of good taste or art."
[10.0] "This stable is very good. It is basically the life's work of Bray Wyatt (RIP) brought to the forefront. The unfortunate part is that Bray is not around anymore to enjoy what is essentially his creation. But it lives on in his memory and it's a fitting tribute to the man as keeping a form of the Wyatt family alive. Too bad, two of the guys from the original group are no longer around to enjoy the glory. Also, WWE, BOOK THESE PEOPLE BETTER!"
[5.0] "I was a HUGE Bray Wyatt / Wyatt Family fan, so the concept of this stable really jumped out to me. Their debut might even have been the best debut of a faction in the past half a decade. But they just didn't ride any momentum. The group was unlucky with injuries and have been sat on the sidelines. I do think they would instantly be a hyped group as soon as they came back again but I am not sure I can realistically see them winning any championships, singles or tag."
[8.0] "The Wyatt Sicks have surprised me, the idea is incredible, using the Firefly Fun House puppets to create them. Everything is perfect, the members, the introduction story, this whole aura they have. I'm eagerly waiting to see their return. But to be honest, I have my doubts. Right now, there are few stables with enough members to face the Wyatts. I think it would be good if they looked for 1 vs. 1 or tag team matches. I'm also doubting how they work; they go away for a long time, then appear, do matches, and leave again. I wish they were more consistent"
[0.0] "It's a knock off/tribute with heavy emphasis on the former. This would be like remaking First Blood with Frank Stallone and Richard Crenna's best friend as Col. Trautman. They're a spooky bunch but there's a BIG reason why they're not featured in anything important. They're not that good and it appears a majority of fans aren't really that interested either. Sometimes it's best to just let things stay in the past. The time to capitalize on this stable has passed and now it's just white noise that very few fans are interested in. They showed up like a steaming hot burrito and left as a wet fart. Let Bray Wyatt and his legacy rest and move on."
[9.0] "I had my doubts about the Wyatt Sicks but wow, they have been booked incredibly well so far. Giving the group a motivation and a rationale has made a big difference. Explaining that these wrestlers are not supernatural beings but frustrated humans paying tribute to Bray is a game changer. The crowds are super into everything they've done so far, they're one of the hottest acts in the company. We'll see where they go from here."
"a great group with alot of potential, just sadly dealt with a injury bug that has kept them off TV. BO Has done a good job with carrying on his brothers legacy story wise. just wish people would give them more of a chance"
[7.0] "Their debut was insane and possibly one of the best debuts of the 2020s, but so far, it hasn't gone so well cause they aren't around as much as we thought they would be. Which is upsetting and annoying cause this faction has and still has so much potential. This would've gotten an 8 or 9 if they showed up more often, but with their booking, I'm giving them a 7."
[5.0] "Where are the Wyatt Sicks? When they debuted, their first month was filled with heart wrenching VHS tapes (CINEMA) and a fun feud with Gable and American Alpha. Now they've just lost a feud to Final Testament and the Miz and have not been seen since. Really disappointing because their hype was SO HIGH."
[2.0] "It's been rough going for the Wyatt Sicks. After a pretty awesome debut, they've been booked really inconsistently and have struggled to get TV time. The feud with the Miz seems like it was going somewhere but they haven't appeared in like a month and it looks like they're moving to Smackdown now so it's pretty clear that the WWE has little clue what to do with them. I'm not gonna lie, I don't really buy Bo Dallas as the eccentric Bray Wyatt cult leader type either, he lacks that charisma and size and looks a little odd doing the Sister Abigail. They keep repackaging and repacking Rowan and Nikki Cross and it never seems to work. Lumis clearly has the most talent of the group but other than that match with the Miz I feel like he's barely been featured. We'll see if this goes anywhere on SD, but it's hard to rate them high when they barely wrestle and I can't even get ironic value out of them like a group like the Truth Commission or Spirit Squad."
[5.0] "I'm still convinced that their group is fighting traitors, even if they don't directly relate to the Wyatt Sicks or the late Bray Wyatt. And now I understand more and more that Uncle Howdy and his puppets are pursuing the goal of continuing Bray Wyatt's legacy, doing the same thing he did as The Fiend. The group wins for the sake of winning - it gives nothing to either them or their opponents. Let's take the same feud with American Made, which began so enchanting, and ended with ... the disappearance of the winners? They faded away with sight, when the losers, made in America, should have done so - but AM, as if nothing had happened, continued to appear on RAW. I didn't understand anything at all about the confrontation with Final Testament. How did it end? Karrion Kross said the Wyatt Sicks went to SmackDown. Great! Oh yeah, the last FT match ended with Karrion Kross, The Miz, and AoP winning. That's it? Many of Bray Wyatt's rivalries also ended if he lost. Goldberg and Randy Orton won't lie. But to be fair, Wyatt was insanely charismatic, and his segments were pretty creative. These guys go around attacking everyone. And they're considered as fighters for justice, well, they're doing a good deed, attacking for revenge. Joe Gacy made fun of this as an SJW fanatic in NXT - and it was an interesting gimmick. Dexter Lumis was insanely cool when he competed with The Miz in 2022. Even Erick Rowan and Bo Dallas were interesting before they tried on these new gimmicks. You can wear a lot of feathers and beaks, send out a bunch of QR codes and turn off the lights until you're dead, but a real genius is in the head and the heart - and this group either has no soul, or the creative department has no soul, which probably limits Bo Dallas in making any decisions"
[8.0] "Bray Wyatt tribute act that so far has been amazing. Worked far better than I expected and their focus on feuding with those who betray their former allies gives them an interesting touch. They have a ton of charisma with these roles, and they can deliver in the ring."
"not going to rate them as it still feels early. but im really liking how theyre presented. then the two matches theyve had have been pretty enjoyable. im just wondering if theres an end goal for them that theyre building up too. cause it just feels like theyre there cause the idea was good which I dint mind. just would like them to have a direction after there 1st feud. cause I dont see the point of them messing with the final testament. will update later on"
[10.0] "This is a faction that became instantly over before they even debuted. The QR code stuff was a whole lot of fun and really helped with the remembering Bray Wyatt part of the group. Then that debut. Oh my gosh. Absolutely incredible. Some of the greatest television that WWE ever did. And they are so popular that literally every single time they appear gets some of the loudest cheers of the night. Their matches are also so intriguing and fun. It helps that everything they do asks questions and makes people wonder what is to come next. Not in a bad way, but in a way that everyone is clearly invested and curious."
[2.0] "I've waited three months before rating this stable, just to give them time and it is exactly what I thought it was going to be. Another awful spooky thing that only exists out of nostalgia due to Bray Wyatt's tragic passing. Every single thing about this stable look cheap and yet they are going to run through everybody just because. I actually liked Joe Gacy in NXT, same goes for Nikki Cross, Dexter Lumis or Rowan but I have no interest in that whole thing. Add to this that 3 of the 5 members have ZERO connection to Bray Wyatt which makes the whole thing nonsensical. The revisionism here is impressive, everything that involved Wyatt ever since the end of the Wyatt Family have always damaged either his opponents or himself and this stable won't be any different, they already killed any ounce of credibility from Chad Gable's new stable."
[2.0] "Every now and then I look at folks like Gunther and Sami Zayn doing great work and think maybe I should give WWE a shot because they have people I like. I jump on Youtube and get caught up with what is going on and think to myself watching them tear it up is not a bad way to spend time. Then I see something as laughably bad as the Wyatt Sicks and think "ohhh no, it is still a product for morons who don't know better" and save myself hours of time per week. In a way I am thankful for it. By all accounts Windham Rotunda was a lovely man who was taken from us way too young but he also had the worst gimmick in wrestling history with a legacy of embarrassing segments and matches so bad it made a WWE audience chant AEW. You should honour the man, not the awful gimmick."
[10.0] "A complete tribute to the work and legacy of Bray Wyatt, the dark aura and characters are there and I can't stop remembering those moments with Bray Wyatt as the World Eater and The Fiend, they are potential tag team champions, which I hope that happens, 10/10 and RIP Bray Wyatt/Windham Rotunda"
[10.0] "As a diehard Bray Wyatt fan this group has been everything and more to me. I wanted Bray Wyatt to be the top star of wwe so badly and I genuinely feel he was during his initial Fiend run but TOO MUCH vince got in the way of it. It breaks my heart that Bray isnt here anymore to give us incredible moments but I am so grateful for everyone in this group keeping his legendary career and spirit alive, especially his brother Bo, who has had incredible promos, presentation, and character work as Uncle Howdy. I really hope this group gets to be as big as humanly possible and I have faith Bo will make this run unforgettable."
[10.0] "This stable will be dominate in the future, storytelling are interesting, all male guys make progress in ring. Still wait for Nikki in-ring new gimmick debut. Windham would be very proud."
[9.0] "The aura of this faction is there, and the awesome representation they have been gifted every week is amazing. VHS tapes are unique ways to dive into the individuals inside the faction. They seem to work nicely together to create that fun but sinister supernatural faction. They don't need titles when the audiences love the unique aspects this faction holds. I would give this a higher however, they are only just starting, but they have major promise and great homage towards Bray Wyatt and Luke Harper (Brodie Lee)."
[10.0] "You just can't give anything other than 10, one of the best things on raw, if not the best, everything they do is exciting and after that powerbomb spot im excited to see more, crowd is behind them and i think they won't fail. I also have to say that Dexter Lumis really surprised me by his appearance."
[1.0] "A faction that only showed VHS tapes to doing the same thing, attacking Chad Gable. Erick Rowan is the only one from this group that I actually like. These people are the most boring thing in the WWE today. 1/10"
[8.0] "I dont know why this faction is so underrated on here, because they are so new and I have loved their work so far. They havent had a match yet, but their presentation and the vignettes have been great."
[10.0] "Just from there debut they are going to treat Uncle howdy better, and really the hype was so worth the wait, im happy that they are able to Honor Bray Wyatt and the Wyatt Family."
[10.0] "I'm a huge fan of the OG Wyatt Family, after seeing the months of teases then seeing the whole debut of the faction on recent Monday Night RAW I'm very excited to see what they do ahead. I think this group can achieve things as long they don't get overbooked or overpowered they will be fine. Happy Taylor can continue his brother Windham legacy."
