[5.0] "On knowhow and atmosphere alone, this has a pretty respectable floor, particularly with Nemeth still bumping around like there's no tomorrow. Unfortunately, Matt Hardy seemingly got shaken up along the way, which ensured that this wouldn't climb much beyond that floor. I do find the Nemeths shtick to be cute though, embracing the automatic heat on Ryan while smartly tasking Nic with the heavy lifting. **1/2"
[5.0] "It was a bit stressful to see Matt Hardy trying to perform, while Jeff looked fairly better & more conscious of what's happening around the ring. On the other hand, Nic was the better Nemeth out of the duo which resulted in Ryan being nothing but a painful comedic act. This is the whole crux of this match! Having one-halves of both teams carry this match to a watchable level isn't the worst aspect in the world, but I'm glad that The Hardys had a fine run as nostalgic champs and dropped the titles to someone who could be more proactive and appealing enough as heel champs. 2.5 out of 5 stars!"
[6.0] "honestly kinda bland in the beginning just a basic tag match that didn't have much behind it but honestly i cared more even though it wasn't the most over the top entertaining match ive ever seen but the story coming into the match i really really enjoyed so that for sure helped things for me. Wasn't shocked the hardy's dropped the belts super excited and interested in the run the nemeths are gonna have. 3.25 stars"
[4.0] "The crowd was hot for this which is what pushed it up, the action itself was pretty slow and uninspired as the Hardys just play the hits while Ryan isn't all that good. This also got just over the line of wearing out its welcome as a viewer."
[3.0] "This match was mostly just headlocks, elbow drops and a lot of posing. It's kinda sad watching the Hardys wrestle these days. Their entrance song will always be legendary, but once the music stops and the bell rings that excitement is completely gone. Matt stumbling over the referee to break up his own team's pinfall is where he's at in his career. Making Nic Nemeth's brother a TNA Tag Team champ is classic TNA. On a PPV as well!"
[3.0] "About one and-a-half good wrestlers in this match. Obviously, Ryan is awful and Matt Hardy can't walk. This was a solidly enjoyable match but kind of in a way that makes you want to laugh AT it instead of respect the work going on in the match."
[4.0] "I hope Matt Hardy is finally happy with this lifetime achievement title run. The Hardys just aren't there anymore. They need to either retire or only do some part time matches, preferably in 6 or 8 man tags for fun. The Nemeths are...there. Nic is great but Ryan wouldn't be anywhere near a title without his brother and he has a fraction of the in ring ability. Fairly abysmal match."
[5.0] "[2.50/5.00]: It was a decent match, but Ryan's long-standing booking as a loser really hurts his credibility. Trying to take him seriously only makes it harder to invest in his character, and that's a major setback. The finish was fun though."
[7.0] "This match was actually pretty good started of slow but picked up towards the end when Nick and Jeff start wrestling. The Finnish was good as well because it suits the gimmick."
[5.0] "Not bad for pre-retirement Hardys and Ryan Nemeth. The ending was fun and in character. Looking forward to the inevitable Ladder match down the line, hopefully TAFKA Ziggler will show up to show off."
