| 43 | Sage | 23.04.2022 | 733 days | Nutley, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| | VACANT | 23.04.2022 | <1 day | | | |
| 42 | Charles Gaston | 21.08.2021 | 245 days | Nutley, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| | VACANT | 21.08.2021 | <1 day | | | |
| 41 | Dracko | 04.03.2017 | 1631 days | Nutley, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 40 | Roman Zachary (6) | 05.03.2016 | 364 days | Nutley, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 39 | Shawn Donavan (2) | 02.05.2015 | 308 days | Nutley, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 38 | Roman Zachary (5) | 10.05.2013 | 722 days | Manville, New Jersey, USA | 9 | Matches |
| | INFO | | | | 8 | |
| 37 | Kevin Knight (8) | 30.10.2011 | 558 days | Woodland Park, New Jersey, USA | 7 | Matches |
| 36 | Travis Blake (2) | 22.10.2011 | 8 days | Woodland Park, New Jersey, USA | 6 | Matches |
| | VACANT | 15.10.2011 | 7 days | | 5 | |
| 35 | Flex Freeman | 16.07.2011 | 91 days | Woodland Park, New Jersey, USA | 4 | Matches |
| | VACANT | 16.07.2011 | <1 day | | | |
| 34 | Franciz (2) | 20.11.2010 | 238 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 33 | Chachi | 22.10.2010 | 29 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 32 | Chris Steeler (2) | 26.06.2010 | 118 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 31 | Fady Madani | 21.05.2010 | 36 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 30 | Kevin Knight (7) | 20.02.2010 | 90 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 29 | Chris Steeler | 21.02.2009 | 364 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 28 | Kevin Knight (6) | 18.05.2008 | 279 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | 3 | Matches |
| 27 | Travis Blake | 17.02.2008 | 91 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 26 | Tony Torres (2) | 01.09.2007 | 169 days | Paterson Falls, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| | VACANT | xx.08.2007 | ? | | | |
| 25 | Franciz | 21.07.2007 | ? | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 24 | Tony Torres | 17.11.2006 | 246 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 23 | Shawn Donavan | 19.08.2006 | 90 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 22 | Kevin Knight (5) | 20.05.2006 | 91 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 21 | Dan McGuire | 22.04.2006 | 28 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 20 | Kevin Knight (4) | 22.10.2005 | 182 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 19 | Damian Adams | 28.08.2005 | 55 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | 2 | Matches |
| | VACANT | xx.xx.2005 | ? | | | |
| 18 | Roman (4) | 17.04.2005 | ? | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 17 | Fred Sampson (2) | 21.01.2005 | 86 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 16 | Roman (3) | 17.01.2004 | 370 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 15 | Fred Sampson | 17.05.2003 | 245 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 14 | Kevin Knight (3) | 22.03.2003 | 56 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 13 | Biggie Biggs | 15.06.2002 | 280 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 12 | Roman (2) | 03.06.2001 | 377 days | West Orange, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 11 | Kevin Knight (2) | 28.04.2001 | 36 days | West Paterson, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 10 | Roman | 21.01.2001 | 97 days | West Orange, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 9 | Kevin Knight | 06.05.2000 | 260 days | Nutley, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 8 | Twiggy Ramirez (2) | 09.10.1999 | 210 days | Nutley, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 7 | Rik Ratchet (3) | 22.06.1999 | 109 days | South Plainfield, New Jersey, USA | 1 | Matches |
| 6 | Lance Diamond | 22.06.1999 | <1 day | South Plainfield, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 5 | Twiggy Ramirez | 20.03.1999 | 94 days | Nutley, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 4 | Rik Ratchet (2) | 30.01.1999 | 49 days | Verona, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 3 | Lupus | 23.01.1999 | 7 days | South Plainfield, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 2 | Rik Ratchet | 10.10.1998 | 105 days | Nutley, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
| 1 | Don Montoya | 14.03.1998 | 210 days | Nutley, New Jersey, USA | | Matches |
#