| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 17.06.2023 |  |
AWWA Heavyweight Title: Guile Castle defeats Jay Garland (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! SCW Heatwave - Event @ Luke-Greenway American Legion Post 1 in Phoenix, Arizona, USA |
| 2 | 17.06.2023 | |
SCW Heavyweight Title: Bloodline defeats Jay Garland (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! SCW Heatwave - Event @ Luke-Greenway American Legion Post 1 in Phoenix, Arizona, USA |
| 3 | 19.05.2023 |  |
AWWA World Heavyweight Title Tournament Final Three Way Match (vakant): Jay Garland defeats Martin Oceans and Trever Aeon - TITLE CHANGE !!! AWWA Revenge - Online Stream @ Cherokee County Recreation Center in Woodstock, Georgia, USA |
| 4 | 19.05.2023 | |
SCW Heavyweight Title: Jay Garland (c) defeats Guile Castle AWWA Revenge - Online Stream @ Cherokee County Recreation Center in Woodstock, Georgia, USA |
| 5 | 15.04.2023 | |
SCW Tag Team Title: Jay Garland & Pete The Heat (c) defeat Money Power Respect (Fabuloso Fabricio & Marco Mayur) SCW One Night In Phoenix - Event @ Luke-Greenway American Legion Post 1 in Phoenix, Arizona, USA |
| 6 | 28.01.2023 |  |
Chris Evans defeats Jay Garland STAR Pro 4th Year Anniversary Show! - Event @ The Cages Training Facility in Phoenix, Arizona, USA |
| 7 | 06.08.2022 | |
STAR Pro Heavyweight Title #1 Contendership: El Dragon defeats Jay Garland STAR Pro Nuclear Heat - Event @ The Cages Training Facility in Phoenix, Arizona, USA |
| 8 | 21.05.2022 | |
Da Shade defeats Jay Garland STAR Pro/SCW Rage At The Cages - Event @ The Cages Training Facility in Phoenix, Arizona, USA |
| 9 | 26.02.2022 |  |
MONSTER Qualifying Five Way: Dallas King & MBW defeat Aguila & Mike G and Akira Gonzalez X & Mercury Yaden and Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete The Heat) and Los Suavecitos (Danny Rose & Ricky Gomez) IZW MONSTER 2022 - Event @ Sun Studios Of Arizona in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 10 | 28.08.2021 | |
Grand Prix First Round: The Regulators (EJ Sparks & Thugnificent) defeat Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete The Heat) IZW Grand Prix - Event @ Sun Studios Of Arizona in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 11 | 21.09.2018 |  |
Jay Garland, The Man In The Hood & Thugnificent vs. LJ Ramos & The Brothers Of Wrestling (Evan Daniels & R-Three) - No Contest SCW Battle Lines - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 12 | 17.08.2018 | |
SCW Tag Team Title Ladder Match (vakant): Jay Garland & The Man In The Hood defeat The Brothers Of Wrestling (Evan Daniels & R-Three) - TITLE CHANGE !!! SCW Big Trouble In Little Mesa - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 13 | 20.07.2018 | |
R-Three defeats Jay Garland SCW The Future Is Now - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 14 | 06.04.2018 |  |
PHW Multiverse Tag Team Title: Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) vs. The Uninvited (Alex Salyers & Oliver Grimsly) - No Contest PHW Hotdogs And Handshakes - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 15 | 09.03.2018 | |
PHW Multiverse Tag Team Title: Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) defeat The Uninvited (Alex Salyers & Johnny Saovi) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PHW Live Free Or Party Hard - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 16 | 12.01.2018 | |
Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) defeat Bradley Banister & Ray Basura PHW Partymania 2 - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 17 | 08.12.2017 | |
Six Man Tag Team Tinsel Town Street Fight: Shane Marvel & The Midnight Marvels (Damian Drake & Spyder Warrior) defeat Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) & EJ Sparks PHW Another Holiday Special - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 18 | 10.11.2017 | |
PHW Multiverse Tag Team Title #1 Contendership Three Way: The Uninvited (Alex Salyers & Johnny Saovi) defeat The Midnight Marvels (Damian Drake & Spyder Warrior) and Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) PHW Cool Intentions - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 19 | 13.10.2017 |  |
Alvaric Reiner defeats Jay Garland by DQ AWF Unleashed - Friday The 13th - Event @ AWF Arena in Glendale, Arizona, USA |
| 20 | 13.10.2017 | |
Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) defeat The Dastardly Duo (Alvaric Reiner & CLAS) AWF Unleashed - Friday The 13th - Event @ AWF Arena in Glendale, Arizona, USA |
| 21 | 06.10.2017 | |
Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) defeat The Uninvited (Johnny Saovi & Oliver Grimsly) PHW Drop Dead - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 22 | 08.09.2017 | |
The Midnight Marvels (Damian Drake & Spyder Warrior) defeat Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) PHW Party Kingdom - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 23 | 19.07.2017 | |
The Dastardly Duo (Alvaric Reiner & CLAS) defeat Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) AWF Unleashed On YT! - Event @ AWF Arena in Glendale, Arizona, USA |
| 24 | 12.05.2017 | |
PHW Multiverse Tag Team Title Match (vakant): Brother Club (Evan Daniels & R-3) defeat Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PHW Season Finale - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 25 | 10.03.2017 | |
Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) defeat Game Sharks (Adan Reyes & Johnny Saovi) PHW Cabin Fever - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 26 | 09.12.2016 | |
Tinsel Town Tag Team Street Fight: Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) defeat Jax & Mason PHW Holiday Special - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 27 | 09.09.2016 | |
Cookies 'N' Cream (Jay Garland & Pete Petroselli) defeat Jax & Mason PHW Animal House - Event @ The Nile Theater in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 28 | 03.10.2015 |  |
Hurricane Hector defeats Jay Garland XCW - Event @ Southern New Mexico State Fair and Rodeo in Las Cruces, New Mexico, USA |
| 29 | 07.02.2015 |  |
Five Points Street Fight: Brute 66 (Mosh Pit Mike & Ray Basura) defeat Jay Garland & THE Josh Carey DWO The Show - Event @ Pat McKernan Event Center in Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA |
| 30 | 18.10.2014 | |
Ten Man Elimination: Alexander Hammerstone, Awesome Andy, Danny Gee, The Hawaiian Lion & The Prophet defeat Adrian Hawkins, Clutch, Jay Garland, Magod Ali & Pali Prince AWF The Elimination - Event @ Peoria Community Center in Peoria, Arizona, USA |
| 31 | 20.09.2014 | |
Alexander Hammerstone defeats Jay Garland AWF Retribution - Event @ Peoria Community Center in Peoria, Arizona, USA |
| 32 | 09.08.2014 | |
Jay Garland defeats Alex Sinister AWF Overdrive 2014 - Event @ Peoria Community Center in Peoria, Arizona, USA |
| 33 | 21.06.2014 | |
Awesome Andy defeats Jay Garland AWF All-American Grand Slam 2014 - Event @ Peoria Community Center in Peoria, Arizona, USA |
| 34 | 15.06.2014 | |
Lucha Star defeats Jay Garland XCW - Event @ El Paso, Texas, USA |
| 35 | 18.05.2014 |  |
Two On One Handicap: Alexander Hammerstone & Jay Garland defeat Spectre AOW Pride Of The Ring 2014 - Tag 2 - Event @ Amistad High School in Indio, California, USA |
| 36 | 25.07.2013 |  |
Jay Garland defeats Magod Ali CWFAZ Fan Appreciation Night - Event @ Arizona, USA |
| 37 | 08.06.2013 | |
CWFAZ Heavyweight Title #1 Contendership: Graves vs. Jay Garland - Time Limit Draw CWFAZ - Event @ Arizona, USA |
| 38 | 13.04.2013 | |
CWFAZ Heavyweight Title #1 Contendership Battle Royal: Winner: Jay Garland CWFAZ - Event @ Arizona, USA |
| 39 | 22.07.2012 |  |
Jay Garland, Jayson Cash & Kid Vegas defeat The Hater Nation (???, ??? & ???) FSW No Escape - Event @ Sam's Town Hotel & Gambling Hall in Las Vegas, Nevada, USA |
| 40 | 04.12.2011 |    |
Jay Garland & Mario Banks defeat Young Hollywood (Brandon Parker & Todd Chandler) NWA Championship Wrestling From Hollywood TV Taping - Event @ Glendale Solar Studios in Glendale, California, USA |
| 41 | 06.11.2011 | |
SoCal Inferno (Espiritu Infernal & SoCal Crazy) defeat Jay Garland & Mario Banks NWA Championship Wrestling From Hollywood TV Taping - Event @ The Regent Showcase Theater in Los Angeles, California, USA |
| 42 | 09.10.2011 | |
Hector Canales defeats Jay Garland NWA Championship Wrestling From Hollywood #58 - TV-Show @ The Regent Showcase Theater in Los Angeles, California, USA |
| 43 | 11.09.2011 | |
Eric Watts defeats Jay Garland NWA Championship Wrestling From Hollywood #54 - TV-Show @ The Regent Showcase Theater in Los Angeles, California, USA |
| 44 | 24.04.2011 |  |
Two On One Handicap: Johnny Stamboli defeats Jay Garland & JB Badd EXW Adrenaline Rush TV Taping - Event @ Toby Keiths Bar & Grill in Meza, Arizona, USA |
| 45 | 06.11.2010 |  |
Cedric Pain defeats Jay Garland PWA Fall Frenzy 2010 - Event @ Clear Lake Community Sports & Recreation Complex in Houston, Texas, USA |
| 46 | 07.05.2010 |  |
Jay Garland defeats Vansack Acid IZW - Event @ Whitman Elementary School in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 47 | 05.02.2010 | |
Jay Garland defeats Sergio Vega IZW - Event @ Fulton Elementary School in Chandler, Arizona, USA |
| 48 | 12.12.2009 |  |
Jay Garland defeats Johnny Starr RPW - Event @ Walker Butte School Gym in San Tan Valley, Arizona, USA |
| 49 | 20.11.2009 | |
Jay Garland defeats Johnny Manson IZW - Event @ Holmes Elementary in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 50 | 06.11.2009 | |
Jay Garland defeats Derrick Neikirk IZW - Event @ Hull Elementary School in Chandler, Arizona, USA |
| 51 | 24.10.2009 | |
NWA Arizona Heavyweight Title Tournament First Round: Jay Garland defeats Terex RPW NWA Arizona Heavyweight Title Tournament - Event @ Broadway Recreation Center in Meza, Arizona, USA |
| 52 | 24.10.2009 | |
NWA Arizona Heavyweight Title Tournament Semi Final: Scorpio Sky defeats Jay Garland RPW NWA Arizona Heavyweight Title Tournament - Event @ Broadway Recreation Center in Meza, Arizona, USA |
| 53 | 09.09.2009 | |
Frenchy Rivera defeats Jay Garland by DQ IZW - Event @ RITC Training Center in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 54 | 11.08.2009 | |
IZW Heavyweight Title Three Way: Dean Radford (c) defeats Frenchy Riviera and Jay Garland IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 55 | 21.05.2009 | |
NWA Arizona Heavyweight Title / IZW Heavyweight Title: Dean Radford defeats Jay Garland (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 56 | 05.05.2009 | |
NWA Arizona Heavyweight Title / IZW Heavyweight Title Three Way: Jay Garland (c) defeats Derrick Neikirk and GQ Gallo IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 57 | 21.04.2009 | |
IZW Heavyweight Title / NWA Arizona Heavyweight Title: Jay Garland (c) defeats Tommy Drake IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 58 | 07.04.2009 | |
IZW Heavyweight Title / NWA Arizona Heavyweight Title: Jay Garland defeats GQ Gallo (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 59 | 24.03.2009 | |
Three Way: Jay Garland defeats Dean Radford and John Williams IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 60 | 21.03.2009 | |
Lucha Reigns defeats Jay Garland IZW - Event @ Eva's Fine Mexican Food Restaurant in Casa Grande, Arizona, USA |
| 61 | 10.03.2009 | |
Jay Garland defeats Nick DeMichael IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 62 | 24.02.2009 | |
Ryan Lynch & Sergio Vega defeat Jay Garland & Lucha Reigns IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 63 | 10.02.2009 | |
Dean Radford defeats Jay Garland IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 64 | 30.01.2009 | |
Lawrence Tyler defeats Jay Garland IZW - Event @ Fulton Elementary School in Chandler, Arizona, USA |
| 65 | 27.01.2009 | |
IZW Impulse Title: Ryan Lynch (c) defeats Jay Garland IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 66 | 13.01.2009 | |
Sergio Vega defeats Jay Garland IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 67 | 30.12.2008 | |
IZW Impulse Title: Ryan Lynch (c) & Nick DeMichael defeat Jay Garland & Peter Goodman IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 68 | 16.12.2008 | |
Sergio Vega defeats Jay Garland IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 69 | 02.12.2008 | |
Jay Garland defeats Nick DeMichael IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 70 | 04.11.2008 | |
IZW Impulse Title Triple Threat: Ryan Lynch (c) defeats Antonio Mestre and Jay Garland IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 71 | 25.10.2008 | |
Ryan Lynch defeats Jay Garland IZW - Event @ Basha High School in Chandler, Arizona, USA |
| 72 | 21.10.2008 | |
Antonio Mestre vs. Jay Garland - Time Limit Draw IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 73 | 07.10.2008 | |
IZW Impulse Title: Ryan Lynch defeats Jay Garland (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 74 | 23.09.2008 | |
IZW Impulse Title: Jay Garland (c) defeats Ryan Lynch IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 75 | 09.09.2008 | |
IZW Impulse Title: Jay Garland (c) defeats Ryan Lynch IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 76 | 26.08.2008 | |
IZW Impulse Title: Jay Garland (c) defeats Marty Murphy IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 77 | 12.08.2008 | |
IZW Impulse Title: Jay Garland (c) defeats Payed Daily IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 78 | 29.07.2008 | |
IZW Impulse Title: Jay Garland defeats Ryan Lynch (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 79 | 15.07.2008 | |
IZW Heavyweight Title / NWA Arizona Heavyweight Title Five Way Elimination: GQ Gallo defeats Lawrence Tyler (c) and Jay Garland and John Williams and Navajo Warrior - TITLE CHANGE !!! IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 80 | 01.07.2008 | |
GQ Gallo defeats Jay Garland IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 81 | 17.06.2008 | |
John Williams & Navajo Warrior defeat Jay Garland & Lawrence Tyler IZW 4th Anniversary - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 82 | 03.06.2008 | |
IZW Heavyweight Title / NWA Arizona Heavyweight Title: Jay Garland defeats Lawrence Tyler (c) by DQ IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 83 | 06.05.2008 | |
Hawaiian Lion vs. Jay Garland - No Contest IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 84 | 22.04.2008 | |
IZW Tag Team Title & NWA Arizona Tag Team Title Two On One Handicap: Skull And Bones (Mike James & The Dread Pirate Bernie) (c) defeat Jay Garland IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 85 | 08.04.2008 | |
Jay Garland defeats Ryan Lynch IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 86 | 08.04.2008 | |
Jay Garland defeats Sergio Vega IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 87 | 25.03.2008 | |
IZW Heavyweight Title / NWA Arizona Heavyweight Title: Lawrence Tyler (c) defeats Jay Garland IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 88 | 11.03.2008 | |
Triple Threat: Jay Garland defeats AJ Summers and Hawaiian Lion IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 89 | 08.03.2008 | |
IZW Heavyweight Title / NWA Arizona Heavyweight Title Four Way: Lawrence Tyler (c) defeats AJ Summers and Hawaiian Lion and Jay Garland IZW - Event @ From Broadway Rec. Center in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 90 | 01.03.2008 | |
Jay Garland defeats Lucha Reigns IZW/WPW - Event @ Sky City Casino in Acoma, New Mexico, USA |
| 91 | 26.02.2008 |  |
Two On One Handicap: The Big Show defeats Jay Garland & Joey Ryan WWE Friday Night SmackDown #445 - TV-Show @ Tucson Convention Center in Tucson, Arizona, USA |
| 92 | 12.02.2008 | |
Jay Garland defeats Payed Daily IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 93 | 29.01.2008 | |
The 602 Wrecking Crew (Jacob Herzberg & Marty Murphy) defeat Hawaiian Lion & Jay Garland IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 94 | 15.01.2008 | |
Hawaiian Lion vs. Jay Garland - No Contest IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 95 | 05.01.2008 | |
IZW Invitational Tournament Final Three Way: AJ Summers defeats Antonio Mestre and Jay Garland IZW - Event @ Broadway Recreation Center in Mesa, Arizona, USA |
| 96 | 18.12.2007 | |
Jay Garland defeats Tony Trouser IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 97 | 04.12.2007 | |
Jay Garland defeats James Freeman IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 98 | 01.12.2007 |  |
Jake Hersberg defeats Jay Garland XJAM - Event @ Chandler, Arizona, USA |
| 99 | 20.11.2007 | |
Mucha Reigns defeats Jay Garland IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
| 100 | 06.11.2007 | |
Jay Garland defeats David Taylor IZW - Event @ The Sets in Tempe, Arizona, USA |
