| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 02.11.2019 - today | PCW Television Champion (2x) (as Bobby Shields) | 1634 days | Matches |
| 19.05.2018 - 03.11.2018 | PCW Television Champion (as Bobby Shields) | 168 days | Matches |
| 29.09.2018 - 29.09.2018 | MCW Tag Team Champion (3x) (as Bobby; with Robby) | <1 day | Matches |
| 14.07.2018 - 29.09.2018 | MCW Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Bobby; with Robby) | 77 days | Matches |
| 19.04.2017 - 14.07.2018 | Capitol Wrestling Tag Team Champion (as Bobby Shields; with Stan Stylez as Luxury Muscles Inc) | 451 days | Matches |
| 24.03.2018 - 09.06.2018 | MCW Tag Team Champion (as Bobby; with Robby) | 77 days | Matches |
| 16.09.2017 - 21.10.2017 | ECWA Unified Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Bobby Shields) | 35 days | Matches |
| 12.11.2016 - 21.01.2017 | RWA Cruiserweight Champion (as Bobby Shields) | 70 days | Matches |
| 28.05.2016 - xx.xx.2016 | DCW Heavyweight Champion (as Bobby Shields) | ? | Matches |
| 19.09.2015 - 19.03.2016 | ECWA Mid-Atlantic Champion (as Bobby Shields) | 182 days | Matches |
| 08.03.2014 - 13.11.2015 | PCW Heavyweight Champion (as Bobby Shields) | 615 days | Matches |
| 07.06.2014 - 06.12.2014 | ECWA Unified Heavyweight Champion (as Bobby Shields) | 182 days | Matches |
| 25.02.2012 - 23.06.2012 | APWA World Tag Team Champion (as Bobby Shields; with New Tradition, Chase Stevens, Christian York, Jock Samson and The Stro) | 119 days | Matches |
| 05.12.2010 - 13.02.2011 | WORLD-1 Tag Team Champion (as Bobby Shields; with Kid America) | 70 days | Matches |
| 31.10.2009 - 21.08.2010 | APWF Throwback Champion (as Bobby Shields) | 294 days | Matches |
| xx.xx.2010 - 01.08.2010 | PWO Tag Team Champion (as Bobby Shields; with Bobby Beverly as Sex Appeal) | ? | Matches |
| 05.07.2008 - 20.09.2008 | NWA East Three Rivers Champion (as Bobby Shields) | 77 days | Matches |
| 27.05.2006 - 16.09.2006 | KCW Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Robert Shields; with Christopher LeRusso III as Cash Flow Inc.) | 112 days | Matches |
| 26.03.2005 - 07.05.2005 | KCW Cruiserweight Champion (2x) (as Bobby Shields) | 42 days | Matches |
| 08.01.2005 - 19.02.2005 | KCW Cruiserweight Champion (as Bobby Shields) | 42 days | Matches |
| 03.12.2002 - 29.03.2003 | KCW Tag Team Champion (as Bobby Shields; with Jay Scott) | 116 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| APWA World Tag Team Championship | 119 days |
| APWF Throwback Championship | 294 days |
| Catalyst Wrestling Tag Team Championship | 451 days |
| DCW Heavyweight Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| ECWA Heavyweight Championship (2x) | 217 days |
| ECWA Legacy Championship | 182 days |
| KCW Cruiserweight Championship (2x) | 84 days |
| KCW Tag Team Championship (2x) | 228 days |
| MCW Tag Team Championship (3x) | 154 days |
| PCW Heavyweight Championship | 615 days |
| PCW Television Championship (2x) | 1802 days |
| PRIME Tag Team Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| PWX Three Rivers Championship | 77 days |
| RWA Cruiserweight Championship | 70 days |
| WORLD-1 Tag Team Championship | 70 days |
