| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 20.10.2013 |  |
Johnny Gargano defeats Paul London PRIME Wrestlelution 6 - Event @ Ohio Nets Sports Complex in Parma, Ohio, USA |
| 2 | 20.10.2013 | |
PRIME Title: Johnny Gargano defeats Krimson (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PRIME Wrestlelution 6 - Event @ Ohio Nets Sports Complex in Parma, Ohio, USA |
| 3 | 11.05.2013 | |
PRIME Title: Krimson (c) defeats Johnny Gargano PRIME TV Taping - Event @ Parma, Ohio, USA |
| 4 | 19.04.2013 | |
Bobby Beverly & Johnny Gargano defeat The Dead Wrestling Society (Gory & Kirst) PRIME - Event @ Agora Ballroom in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 5 | 16.02.2013 | |
PRIME Title: Krimson defeats Johnny Gargano (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PRIME Pressure Rising 2013: Megalomania - Pay Per View @ Twinsburg Fitness Center in Twinsburg, Ohio, USA |
| 6 | 18.01.2013 | |
PRIME Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Matt Cross PRIME TV Taping - Event @ Our Lady Of Mt. Carmel in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 7 | 07.12.2012 | |
PRIME Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Gory PRIME TV Taping - Event @ Our Lady Of Mt. Carmel in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 8 | 30.09.2012 | |
PRIME Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Rhino PRIME TV Taping - Event @ Twinsburg, Ohio, USA |
| 9 | 19.08.2012 | |
PRIME Title: Johnny Gargano defeats Jimmy Jacobs (c) (20:00) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PRIME Wrestlelution 5 - Pay Per View @ Jacobs Pavilion in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 10 | 07.08.2011 |  |
Three Way: Matt Cross defeats Johnny Gargano and Josh Prohibition PWO Wrestlelution 4: Overdrive - Pay Per View @ Jacobs Pavilion in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 11 | 10.10.2010 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title: Marion Fontaine defeats Johnny Gargano (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PWO Three Year Anniversary - Event @ Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 12 | 01.08.2010 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Matt Cross PWO Wrestlelution 3: A Defining Moment - Event @ Nautica Pavilion in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 13 | 02.05.2010 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Jason Bane PWO Fallout 2010 - Event @ Eastwood Expo Center in Niles, Ohio, USA |
| 14 | 02.05.2010 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Corey Winters PWO Slamming Into Summer 2010 - Event @ All American Festival in Berea, Ohio, USA |
| 15 | 22.03.2010 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats N8 Mattson PWO WrestleRama 2010 - Tag 3 - Event @ IX Center in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 16 | 21.03.2010 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Bobby Shields PWO WrestleRama 2010 - Tag 2 - Event @ Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 17 | 20.03.2010 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Gregory Iron PWO WrestleRama 2010 - Tag 1 - Event @ Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 18 | 20.02.2010 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Jason Bane PWO Road To WrestleRama 2010 - Event @ Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 19 | 24.01.2010 |  |
PWO Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Bobby Beverly PWO/CWE Expolosion 2010 - Event @ Eastwood Expo Center in Niles, Ohio, USA |
| 20 | 05.12.2009 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Mike Tolar PWO Finale 2009 - Event @ Hispanic Umadod Youth Center in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 21 | 11.10.2009 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Mike Tolar PWO Day Of Legends - Two Year Anniversary Show - Event @ IX Center in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 22 | 09.08.2009 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title No Disqualification: Johnny Gargano defeats Josh Prohibition (c) (28:03) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PWO Wrestlelution 2: A Coming Of Age - Event @ Nautica Pavilion in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 23 | 18.04.2009 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title: Matt Cross (c) defeats Johnny Gargano PWO TV #41 - TV-Show @ Brook Park Recreation Center in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 24 | 13.03.2009 | |
PWO Heavyweight Title #1 Contendership Three Way: Johnny Gargano defeats Jason Bane and Mike Tolar PWO TV #38 - TV-Show @ Brook Park Recreation Center in Brook Park, Ohio, USA |
| 25 | 03.08.2008 | |
Last Man Standing: Johnny Gargano defeats Gregory Iron (18:27) PWO Wrestlelution - Event @ Plain Dealer Pavilion in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 26 | 21.06.2008 | |
Johnny Gargano defeats Super Hentai PWO TV #17 - TV-Show @ Lakewood Masonic Temple in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 27 | 24.05.2008 | |
Johnny Gargano vs. Marion Fontaine - No Contest PWO TV #15 - TV-Show @ Lakewood Masonic Temple in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 28 | 19.04.2008 | |
Jason Bane defeats Johnny Gargano by DQ PWO TV #12 - TV-Show @ Lakewood Masonic Temple in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 29 | 19.04.2008 | |
Jason Bane & Michael Hutter defeat Johnny Gargano & Josh Prohibition PWO TV #13 - TV-Show @ Lakewood Masonic Temple in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 30 | 09.02.2008 | |
Johnny Gargano defeats Benjamin Boone PWO TV #9 - TV-Show @ Lakewood Masonic Temple in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 31 | 09.02.2008 | |
Bane & Matt Cross defeat Johnny Gargano & Josh Prohibition PWO TV #9 - TV-Show @ Lakewood Masonic Temple in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 32 | 15.12.2007 | |
Colin Olsen defeats Johnny Gargano PWO TV #7 - TV-Show @ Lakewood Masonic Temple in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 33 | 15.12.2007 | |
Johnny Gargano & Josh Prohibition defeat The Olsen Twins (Colin Olsen & Jimmy Olsen) (10:47) PWO TV #8 - TV-Show @ Lakewood Masonic Temple in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 34 | 17.11.2007 | |
Johnny Gargano defeats Hobo Joe PWO TV #5 - TV-Show @ Lakewood Masonic Temple in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 35 | 17.11.2007 | |
Johnny Gargano & Josh Prohibition defeat Josh Abercrombie & Marion Fontaine PWO TV #6 - TV-Show @ Lakewood Masonic Temple in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 36 | 20.10.2007 | |
Gregory Iron defeats Johnny Gargano PWO TV #1 - TV-Show @ Lakewood Masonic Temple in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 37 | 20.10.2007 | |
Johnny Gargano & Josh Prohibition defeat John McChesney & Matt Cross PWO TV #3 - TV-Show @ Lakewood Masonic Temple in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
